HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - Minutes - City Council - Meeting Date: 1/10/2017 (6)Caty of Glendale
5850 West Glendale Avenue
Glendale, AZ 85301
t*ry
Meeting tinutes - Final
Tuesday, January 10, 2017
6:00 PM
Votlng Meetlng
Gouncil Chambers
NaytJerryWelets
Wcetayorlan Hugh
Councllmember Janle Aidama
Councllmenber Joyce Clarlc
Cuncllmntber Ray talnar
Courcllmember Launn Tolm*hofr
Cou nc ll member Batt Tu mer
Glty Councll tee0ng illnulea. Flnal January 10,m17
CATLTOORDER
Pnrent 7' MayorJerrylAbiers, Vie Mayorlan Hugh, CouncilnpmberJamieAldama.
Councilmember Joyce Clark, Councilmember Ray Malnar, Councilmember Lauren
Tolmachofi, and Councilmember Bart Turner
Aho present wele KeMn Phelps, City
Michael Bailey, City Attomey; Julie K.
City Clerk.
PLEDGE OFALLEGIANCE
PRAYER/TNVOCAT|ON
Manager; Tom Duensing, Assistrant City Manager:
Bo^,er, City Cl€rk; and Darcie Mc€racken, Deputy
The invocation was ofiered by Samson Dunn of the Catalyst Church.
CITIZENCOMMENTS
Joy (last name unknorn), a Sahuaro resident spoke about dnrgs in the valley. She said
a man was handing out heroin at drug centers and she had gone to s€veral law
enforcement agencies and no one was taking care of the issue.
Ball Demski, a Sahuaro resident, spoke about several acckJenb he had while riding his
bike. Polioe officers had refus€d to take a report. tle said he had filed a comptaint with
the Polloe Department and the offioers were eventually exorcrated fiom any wrongdoing.
He had called the City Maneger and the Police Chief about the incirients and never
r€oeiwd retum phone calls.
James Deibleq a Phoenix reoident, spoke about a strate bill regarding backyard cfrickens.
He also sakj there was a need for a Microsofi store at the Anorhead Mall to bring jobs to
the w€st valley.
John Hunt, a Sahuaro reeident, spoke about the issue of backyad chickens. He did not
stlppotl the bill becawe he did not want to deal wiilr neighbors having chickens or geese
in heir backyards.
APPROVAL OF THE IIINUTES OF DECEMBBR 13, 2016 SPECIAL MEETING AND DECEMBER
2O,2OT6VOTTNG MEETING
16.663 APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF DECEMBER 13,2016 SPECIAL
MEETING AND DECEMBER 20,2016 VOTING MEETTNG
StaffContact Julie K. Bovver, City Clerk
A moton war made by GouncllmemberAldama, seconded by Cornclhnember
Chrk, tfietthb agenda lbm be approved. The mo0on caried by the follorvlng
yote:
Ayo: 7 ' Mayor tAfeiers, Mce Mayor Hugh, Councilmember Aldama, Councilnember Clark,
Councilmember Malnar, Councilmember Tolmachofi and Councilmember Tumer
CONSENTAGENDA
1.
CltydG/rrnfrlc W.r PttuNorrlngmtT
City Councll teedng tinubs. Final January 10,m17
2.1G661
3.16-662
5.16€40
7.16-651
11.16-667
16-668
16-669
14.16-670
12.
Ms. 8orrrcr read cons€nl Resofulion ltem number 15 by number and title.
Mayor \Aleiers said Councilmember Clark requested ltsms 4, 6, 8, 9 and 10 separately.
Mayor VtGiea asked if any Councilmembee wanted to hear any o$er items s€parately.
Councilmember Clark explained she wanted the items pulled so she oould have an
opportunity to reoord her no vote on the five items. She said she would be abdicating her
fiduciary reoponsible as a Councilmember by voting to approve tp lengthy oontracts
because there was no time br a pedodic review of the reqrrsts. Councilmember Clark
would be asking for researcfi into bng term purchase contracts as a council item of
special interest.
RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF SPECIAL EVENT LIQUOR LICENSE,
KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS 7114
Staff Contact Vicki Rios, Director, Budget and Fanance
RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF LIQUOR LICENSE NO. 5.21965,
LUCKrS P'ZZA
Staff Contract: Vicki Rios, Director, Budget and Finance
AWARD OF RFP 17.07 AND AUTHORIZATION TO ENTER INTO AN
AGREEMENT WTH RAFTELIS FINANCIAL CONSULTANTS, INC., TO
PROVIDE FINANCIAL PISNNING AND RATE STUDY SERVICES
Staff Contact Craig Johnson, P.E., Director, Water Services
AWARD OF RFP 17-08 AND AUTHORIZATION TO ENTER INTO AN
AGREEMENT WTH M.P. ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, INC., FOR
SLUDGE EXCAVATION AND HAULING SERVICES
Staff Contact Craig Johnson, P.E., Director, Water Services
AUTHORIZATION FOR A BUDGET APPROPRIATION CONTINGENCY
TMNSFER TO CAPITAL PROJECTS BUILDING MAINTENANCE
RESERVE FOR VARIOUS CRITICAL OR SAFEW.RELATED REPAIR
AND REPLACEMENT PROJECTS AT CITY FACILITIES
StaffContract Jack Friedline, Director, Public Works
AUTHORIZATION TO ENTER INTO AMENDMENT NO. 2 TO THE
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT WTH DIBBLE &
ASSOCIATES CONSULTING ENGINEERS, INC., DOING BUSINESS AS
DIBBLE ENGINEERING, FOR ADDITIONAL DESIGN SERVICES FOR
THE NORTH APRON REHABILITATION PHASE II PROJECT
Staff Contact Jack Friedline, Director, Public Works
AUTHORIZATION TO ENTER INTO A CONSTRUCTION AGREEMENT
WTH ACHEN.GARDNER CONSTRUCTION, L.L.C., FOR THE 47TH
AVENUE STORM DRAIN PROJECT
StaffContact: Jack Friedline, Director, Public Works
AUTHORIZATION TO ENTER INTO AN AGREEMENT WTH SALT RIVER
13.
Cftyo/A,rlrxt/,tue.2 Pttrt do//,tl26/i2u7
City Council
PRoJECT (SRP) TO TNTTTATE DESTGN AND CONSTRUCTION ON THE
SALT RIVER PROJECT AESTHETICS PROJECT LOCATED AT 47TH
AVENUE FROM NORTH OF GLENDALE AVENUE TO NORTHVIEW
AVENUE
Staff Contract Jack Friedline, Director, Public Works
CONSENT RESOLUTIONS
15.16-630 RESOLUTION NO. R17.01
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GLENDALE,
MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA, AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE
ENTERING INTO OF A MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING WTH
THE CITY OF PHOENIX ADMINISTERED BY ITS FIRE DEPARTMENT
FOR TNCTDENT SAFEW OFFTCER SYSTEM (|SOS) TRAINING FOR
GLENDALE FIREFIGHTERS.
StafiContact Terry Ganison, Fire Chief
Approval of the Consent Agenda
A motion war made by Tumer, reconded by Tolmachofi' to apprcve the
ncommendad acdona on ConeentAgenda ltem ilumberr 2,3,6,7 and ll
through 14 and Coment Recoludon 16. The moton canied by the followlng
vob:
Aye: 7 - MayortA/eiers, Mce Mayor Hugh, CouncilmemberAldama, Councilmember
Clail, Courcilmember Malnar, Councilmember Tolmachofi and Councilmember
Turner
16.664 AUTHORIZATION FOR THE PURCHASE OF TABLEAU SOFTWARE
LICENSES, SERVICES, AND MAINTENANCE FROM CDW-G
UTILIZING A COOPERATIVE PURCHASING CONTRACT
Staff Contact Charles Murphy, Chief Information Offcer, Innovation and
Technology
Mr. Murphy sakl thie item was for authorization of the purcfiase of the Tableau
Softrare Business Intelligence Solution. He said Tableau was selecied based on
functionality and ease of use. This purcfiase was being made under a stab contracl,
whicfi expired in2021.
Councilmember Clark had no questions, but went€d the opportuniry to record a no
vote on the item.
Councilmember Tumer asked if the items could be epedited by recoding a no \ote
on all of the atems at onoe.
Mayor lAhiers asked Councilmember Clark if she wanted to hear the items
s€parately.
Councilmember Clark sakl she had no objection with hearing the items allat onoe.
Mayor t/tbiers asked Councilmember Tumer to mow all file items.
teedng tinubr - Flnal January 10,2017
4.
CWo/Araneta Prg.t Prhtod m 1/261tu17
Glty Gouncll ileetng mhubs. Final January 10,m77
8.
6.16-648
16-652
16-653
16-657
flterns 4, 6, 8, 9 and 10 u,€re acted upon in one motion and one vote.l
AWARD OF IFB 17.15 AND AUTHORIZATION TO ENTER INTO AN
AGREEMENT WTH DANA KEPNER COMPANY, INC., FOR LARGE
WATER METERS AND PARTS
Staff Contact Craag Johnson, P.E., Director, Water Services
AUTHORIZATION TO ENTER INTOA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
AGREEMENT WTH INDUSTRIAL AUTOMATION SERVICES, INC., A
SOLE SOURCE PROVIDER, FOR PARTS, EQUIPMENT, AND
SERVICE FOR KROHNE EQUIPMENT
Staff Contact Craig Johnson, P.E., Director, Water Services
AUTHORIZATION TO ENTER INTO A PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
AGREEMENT WTH BALAR HOLDING CORPORATION, DOING
BUSINESS AS BALAR EQUIPMENT, A SOLE SOURCE PROVIDER,
FOR PARTS, EQUIPMENT, AND SERVICE FOR STANLEY TOOLS
AND E.H. WACHS EOUIPMENT
Staff Contact Craig Johnson, P.E., Director, Water Services
AUTHORIZATION TO ENTER INTO AMENDMENT NO. 1 TO THE
AGREEMENT WTH CAL.PACIFIC CARBON, LLC, FOR THE
PURCHASE OF POIA/DERED ACTIVATED CARBON
Staff Contac't: Craig Johnson, P.E., Director, Water Services
A modon wae mede by CouncllmemberTumer, reconded by Vice tayor
Hugh, to approve agenda ltetm 4,6,8,9 and 10. The modon carled by the
followlng vob:
6 - Mayor tAleiers, Me Mayor Hugh, Councilmember Aldama. Councilmember
Malnar, Councilmember Tolmachofi, and Councilmember Tumer
1 - Councilmember Clark
9.
10.
Aye:
Nay:
16.
PUBLIC HEARING . LAND DEYELOPMENT ACTTONS
16-658 oRD|NANCE NO. c1741
AN ORDINANCE OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GLENDALE,
MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA, REZONING PROPERTY LOCATED AT
16480 NORTH 59TH AVENUE FROM C-O (COMMERCTAL OFFTCE) TO
G.O (GENERAL OFFICE);AMENDING THE ZONING lt4AP; PROVIDING
FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND ORDERING THAT A CERTIFIED
COPY OF THIS ORDINANCE IS RECORDED.
StaffContact Jon M. Froke, AICP, Planning Director
Ms. Borer read Ordinanoe No. 017{1.
Mr. Froke said the applicant was requesting to r€zone the property fiorn commercial
offoe to gerrral office zoning district. Rezoning the site would allor br medical use
CWdAtottttu M.tumdqrrnaml?
Clty Councll tee0ng tlnuleo. Flnal January 10,2017
greater than 5,000 square bet. The site was just or,er 2.5 acres and was cunently
vacant. A new single-story building was propoG€d and 28 peroent of the site would be
landscap€d.
Mr. Froke sakl the proposed facility was a plavna colleclion facility and it would be open
Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Nenr ofi-site strreet improvemenb were
planned on both 59th Avenue and Kings Avenue, wlilch included a ne$, souttrbound r[ht
tum lane on 59ttr Avenue onto the site as well as completion of gutter, curb and
sUewalks adiacent to the site. He said the building design would complement the area
and would be positioned adjaoont to 59th Avenue. The building would be located 200 bet
east of near0y single family hornes.
Mr. Froke said the rezoning of the property was consist€nt with the general plan. He said
the Planning Commission unanimously approved the plan, subjec{ to three stipulations.
Councilmember Turner asked if there was oher G-O zoned land in the area and asked
where that land was located.
Mr. Froke said there was G-O zoned prope0 that was located on the nortlr side of Bell
Roed at 63rd Awnue. Fle said that was the neur Honor Heatth facility.
Councilmember Tumer asked if that was the only other G-O zoned property.
Mr. Froke said that was the only other G-O zoned propeny in the aea.
Councilmember Malnar asked what sort of public response was reoeived during the
oommunity meetings that were held.
Mr. Froke sall there urerc ooncems about what type of operations ttrat would oocur at the
phsma €nter, as well as @ncems about traffic in the area. He said there were also site
conoems about placement of walls and landscaping. He explained the applicant agreed
lo defay the item to allow lime br a second neQhborhood meeting about the issue. He
said 10 r€sidenb anended the second meeting.
Councilmember Malnar 6ked what the attendanoe was at the Planning Commission
meeting when the issue was discussed.
Mr. Froke sakl the item was heard by the Planning Commission on Oclober 6th, and
thor€ were 11 sp€akers, all in opposition to he cas€.
Councilmember Malnar asked if the Planning Commission paseed the item unanimously.
Mr. Froke said thal was oonect.
Councilmember Malnar asked ff the Planning Commiseion would have voted in favor of the
proiect if there had been a larger tumout at thet meeting.
Mr. Froke said it was hard to say whictt atetm would draw a lot of interest from the public.
Councilmember Clark asked Mr. Froko to tralk about the purpos€ of C-O zoning.
Mr. Froke sakJ there were several different zoning districils. He said the least intensive
zoning distrid was R-O, and there werent many of thoee In Glendale.
ClUotCtortuto w6 PtffidtqrnumlT
Cfi Councll teetng ltlnubr. Flnel January 10,2017
Councilmember Clark asked about the difbrence between general offoe and cornmercial
ofioe zoning.
Mr. Froke said the next leral of zoning was oommercial offce (CO) which would indude
medical or probssional offoes. He said gercral office (GO) was used to expand the use
of some of thoae fac:ilities and there were not many in Glendale.
Councilmember Clark asked if C-O or G-O zoning was more intense.
Mr. Froke sail G-O zoning was morc intense.
Councilmember Clark asked what other kinds of uses were allored under GO zoning
tlut were not allorcd under CO zoning.
Mr. Froke said the most sBnificant difiErencE between th6 two would be the ovemight
stay at a hospital facility aM there was more intensity allored in a G-O zoning, such as
the height of a building.
Councilmember Clail said sh€ understood that a G-O zoning dlorcd for maror
employment conoentralions and asked what that meant.
Mr. Froke said the Bell Road conidor would be an example of a major employment
concentration
Councilmember Clark asked which of those zoning districts provided a better bufier for
adjaoent rrighborhoods.
Mr. Froke said C-O would probably proMde a better buftr, however G-O would not b€ a
bad neighbor in this cas€, especially wiut tr landscape pad€ge that was being
propos€d.
Councilmember Clark said Mr. Froke said C-O would be the better bufbr.
Mr. Froke said that was conect.
Councilmember Clark asked Mr. Froke's personal opinion on whether 1,000to 1,200
vbits perweek was intense use or benign use.
Mr. Froke sakj he thought it was adequate and appropriate tur an arterial street such as
59Or Avenue.
Councilmember Clark said it might be appropdate br the use, but asked if Mr. Froke
considered that to be an intens€ us€.
Mr. Froke said he did not.
Councilmember Tolmachoff asked if the landscape bufbr wa the only bufbr to the
neighborhood thatwas nearthe proposed site.
Mr. Fmke said rchicular acoess to the site met all the requirements of the Transportation
Department and Public \adorks Depanment. He said both parties believed ther€ wes
adequate aocoss.
Councilmember Tolmachoff asked if the entire bufiEr consisted only of landscape.
C/,yo/Abrtu'r PryC PtffidtonlauntT
Gity Gouncll tee0ng mnu0.s - Flml January l0,m17
Mr. Froke sakt a wall existed that was buift br the subdivision to the west and that wall
would remain in place. There would also be decorative screen walls for tlp parking lots.
Councilmember Tolmachoff asked what type of jobs the pmject would create.
Mr. Froke debned the question to the applicant's presentration.
Councilmember Aldama asked what was the height of the proposed building.
Mr. Froke said the building would be less than 30 bet in height.
Councilmember Aldama asked about the distance ftom the building itself to the homes
thatwerc justwest of the site.
Mr. Froke said the distanoe ftom the building to the resirlential bnce line was 200 b€t.
CouncilmemberAldama asked whatwas located in that 2oGfoot spaoe.
Mr. Froke explained there was a parking lot, hndscaping and storm water retention.
Councilmember Aldama asked hor many plasma donation businesees were located in
Glendale.
Mr. Froke saad ther€ uere three fac;ilities cunenUy in Glendale.
CoundremberAldama said thete $rerc two existing facilities and the one proposed site.
Mr. Froke said that was oon€cl. Mr. Froke said United Blood Services was about a mile
north of the site but did not pay br donations.
Councilmember Aldama asked if fio facility locatEd on Camelback was relocated from
59Or Avenue and Northem.
Mr. Froke said the facility on Camelback had been there for sorne time. The facility on
Norfiem and 51st A\renue Flocated a couple of years ago ftom 59fi Arrenue and
Northem.
CouncilmemberAldama asked ho,r,long those facilities had been located in Glendale.
Mr. Froke said the facility on Camelbad< had been there for about 20 to 25 yeaa. The
facility at 51st and Northem was elocated wihin the last 5 years. He said United Btood
SeMoes had b€€n in ils cun€nt location br 10 to 15 years.
Councilmember Aldama asked af stafi or the Planning Commission requested any recods
ftom the Polie Departnent aboutthe facilities cunenily located in Glendate.
Mr. Froke said no records were r€quested to has kno,vledge and he did rot knor of any
issues with either of thoee facililies.
Mayor tA/eiers asked if the applicant could make thear presentation. He asked for
clarification regarding th€ ttvo existing facilities and if ttrey were plasma centers and if
United Blood SeMces was limited to blood donations.
CnydAM PW7 Prffidutl/i2uiw17
City Councll Itleetng minubg. Flnsl January 10,m17
l(isten Frye, a site manager with BioLab, explained it depend€d on the organization. She
said some blood seMce oqanizations did oollect platelets or plasma as well. She was
not familiar wth the operations of United Blood Servioes. Ms. Frye said BioLib had met
several times with the neighborhood to educate them about Biolife. The Planning
Commission had unanimously approved the project and the plasma canter was a
permitted use in the zoning classification.
Ms. Frye said one con€m expressed by he rrighborhood was the potentiat to draw
undesirable individuals into the community. She said ercry individual was required to
provide govemment-issued identification and proof of address. Every individual was
checked to make surc their address was a home and not a homeless shelter or transient
type motel. She explained finst-time donors were r€quired to complete a physical
examanation and health scmening. Homeless persons w€re not eligible to donab and
loitering was not permitted on fie facility.
Ms. Frye said BioLib obeen/ed all regulations regarding dispoeal of medical waste. They
would be bdnging in about 25 percent less traffic than the maximum dlorcd at the
location. The facility was lioensed and regulated by the FDA. She said the aclual
medical use area of the proposed building wag under 5,000 square ftet. In addition to the
donor and rnedical use area, the building would also house offioes and other non+nedical
use areas, which was the reason for the request br the rezone.
Ms. Frye said proposed faffic would be about 25 percent less than ths maximum
allorted. She said staffing included manegers, registered nuBes and phlebotomisb and
wages were comparable to oher wages for similar lobs in the community. She sail the
proposed building was about 22 feet in height.
Councilmember Clark asked if the majority of the employe€s at the facility drerrv blood or
plasma.
Ms. Frye said staffng varied. Typically around 30 employees were hired. She explained
employees were usually cross.train€d and mbht work in various positions in the building.
Councilmember Clark asked if that type of medical staff was pairl u€ll, and said she was
not talkit€ about managerial staff or the cross-trained staff who worked in several difbrent
aeas of the facility. She was talking abort thooe employees who drew the blood or
plasma.
Ms. Frye said the company looked at salary ranges br the poeitions across ttre country
and evaluated the Glendale wages. She sakl the wages w€rs comparable to positions at
other facilities and training was provided to employees. She did not consider the salades
to be on the lor end of the range. The company also oftred medical, dentral and
vacation benefits to part-time employees.
Mayor Wbiers asked Ms. Frye to explain the process for a brand-nen, customer coming
to the facility.
Ms. Frye said the process included oollecling identification, entering the donor into the
electronic system, review of donor elagabality, obtraining a donor medical history, a general
physical and colbdion of the donation.
Mayor tAleiers asked about the colleclion.
Ms. Frye explained with a single puncture, whole blood was collected and a machine
CltydGbtrdr/o tue.t Prttt do',nmttT
Glty Councll tleetng tlnuler - Flnal January 10,2017
separat€d the plasna from the donation. The whole blood was then refumed to the
donor.
Mayor lAleiers asked how long donoe had to wait between donations.
Ms. Frye said plasma could be donated twice wihin a selonday period, as long as there
was a day separating the donations.
Mayor tAleiers asked if donoe ur€r€ paid br their donations.
Ms. Frye said donoB u,ere oompensated for their time.
MayortAleiers asked hor many centers BioLib cunenily operated.
Ms. Frye said they cunendy operated 85 cenbrs.
Mayor VtGiea asked about the average customer br donations.
Ms. Frye said customeF wer€ between 18 and 99 years of age. She sakl about 85
percent of the donors truer€ working prohssionab, stray-at-horne moms and other citizens.
She said lhe average age of donors was betrveen 18 and 60 years old. The minimum age
to donate was 18 years and there was a minimum uveight requirement of 110 pounds.
Mayor tA/eiers asked Ms. Frye to describe the average recipient of 0re plavna.
Ms. Frye said plavna treated individuals wiUr hemophilia, sereral chronic diseases, bum
and shock victims, as u€ll as others.
Councilmember Tolmachoff asked how mucfi the donors rEceived br a donation.
Ms. Frye said the amount varierl based on the area. She was not really involved in that
aspect but said a donor might receive $20 for their first donation and $30 br their second
donation.
Councilmember Tolmachoff asked hor long the proess took for a rctum donor.
Ms. Frye said the initial prooess took about 2 hours and a retum donation took about 65
minutes.
CouncilmemberTolmachoff *ked if the centerwould allorrwalkjn appoantnents.
Ms. Frye said the center only accepted donors with sche<luled appointnenb through itts
onlane sch€duling system.
Councilmember Clark asked if there was an average of 1,000to 1,200ur€€kly visits to a
collection oenter.
Ms. Frye said it vaded but that figure would be accurate within a year of a oenter opening.
Councilmember Clark asked if this center could see 180 to 200 visits per day.
Ms. Frye saad that was con€d.
Councilmember Malnar asked if a walkin customer would be allored to donate.
CrVo'Atrx,da F.tP,tutuMoa1n6tml7
City Gouncll teetng tlnubc - Flnal January 10,2017
Ms. Frye said if an appointrnent time was available, the center would ty and work that
person in, but there ha<l been times when a donor might be asked to t€tum with an
appointnent.
Councilmember Malnar asked if a walk{n donor would be aoepted if there was an
opening in the appointnent tim6.
Ms. Frye sakJ they would accept that donor if there was an opening.
Mayort/Veiers opened the public h€aring.
Heidi Gustratson, a Sahuaro resklent, was wonied about inqeas€d traffic and sabty of
students at the nearby school. She asked if having the facility would increase drug
adiw in the area and asked if polioe prssencs would be increased due to the increase
in traffic along Kings Avenue. She said the smallest possible facility would be best lf irt
was approved and sakl therc was already a parking probhm in the area.
Laurie Walsh, a Sahuaro resident, said she rcpresented many residents in the audience.
She said donors came for the money they were paid for thEir donation. She sakl a
community reiected this type of center because of the crime it bro4ht to the area and
the increased traffic. She asked that the item be voted donn for the sabty and
preservation of the community.
Steven Parker, a Sahuaro r€sident lived right around lhe comer from the proposed
business. He was not antitusiness, but was asking for a no vote on the issue. He sakJ
the cunent zoning balanoed business and the neighborhood. He saH more people would
increase crime and trafrc in the area. The facility wouE meet he City's need and the
business' need, but dld not meet the needs of the neighborfiood. He was wonied about
the loss an home valt es if Ote facility was built.
Monte Rae, a Sahuaro resident, had oollected signatur€s on the issue and said 82
percant of residenb dkJ not want the p@eci completed. He disputed the donor faffic
figures presented by BioLib and thought lhe haffc would be much hQher. He said there
was already Goodwill and a rehab facility in the ar€a and the plasma center would just
attract more people looking for easy money. He said the taffic would increase in the
nearby neighborhoods, as well.
lGthy Parker, a Sahuaro resklent, saki she understood the City's d$ire to develop the
prop€rty and retrain a r€venue Bouroe. The public was \Ery interested in the issue. She
said they would be afiected by the zoning change decision and would have to tleal wttr
the realiUes. She said the Planning Commission unanimously approved the prolect even
thongh many residents had strenuously objected. She asked the Council to gi\€ careful
consideration to the vote.
Gail Sharp, a Sahuaro resident was not happy with the proiect and trafrc had already
irrreased ftom the Goodwill store. She said there would be no encouragement br the
homeless to leave the area with promise of payment every bw days.
Roger Sharp, a Sahuaro resident, had noticed many mot€ people in his neighborhood
since the Goodri,ill stor€ open€d rrarby, and had been aocooted by homeless people
twice. He did not want the facility in his neighborhood and asked the Council to vote
agaanst it
CWo'Ar.rnt/Prg.10 Ptffi.don126N17
City Councll teetng tinuba. Flnal January 10,2017
Elizabeth Mares, a Sahuaro r$ident, said the City faaled to nofiry more lhan a handful of
rnighbors for the first BioLib meeting. She saki Councilmember Malnar said he would
not want a plasma €nter In his neighborhood. They had many signatu]es on a petition
of everyorr that opposed fie prolect. She had attended fte s€oond BioLib meeting and
was threatened and had to file a police report. She said the Council did not want to ruin
the rrighborhood.
Debbie Boone, a Sahuaro rssident, sakl the parking lot of the proiect was directly behind
her home. She sakl BioLib erd Build to Suit had not addrwsed any of their conoems.
She spoke about thg traffic and crime issues that would occur once fie facility was open.
She asked the Councilto consider opposing the proiec{.
Harry Boone, a Sahuaro resident, provided copies of the sBned rcighborhood pettions to
f|e Caty Clerk. He sakj more traffic in has area would mean more crashes. He also
spoke about the ancrease in crlne in Glendale and said the plasma center would inq€ase
crime in his neighbofiood. He spoke about his experience visiting other plasma enters.
tle asked the Councilto oppose the item.
John Hunt, a Sahuaro resident, had lived near a blood donation facility in the past and
knew the kind of crime that occuned near thos€ locations. l'le said the traffic would be a
nighmae and it would attrad the wrong element into their rnBhbothood. He hoped the
Council voted against the item. He also asked if changing the zoning would allotr the
facility to operate 24 hour a day. lf it was a 2&hour facility, it made the prciect even
more undesirable and lhe neighborhood would have morc probhms.
Jarvi Brorn-Hardy, a Sahuaro resident, said any paid donations wer€ used br cosmetic
and pharmaoeutacal us€. She said the facility was not br medical use and was not
compatible with area uses. ShE spoke about the lou, paying jobs in thes€ types of
fac;ililies. She said the project did not make good marketing sense.
Bill Hutsel, a Sahuaro resklent sakt the faciliU would still be built even if the zoning was
not changed. He spoke about the entranoe to he location and the potential increase in
tnaffic. He sairJ he might consider moving out of the neighborhood. He asked the Council
to considervoting no on the item.
Ken Tharp, a Sahuaro resident, said he lived cloee to the proposed facility. He was
concemed about the Planning Commission's decision to approve the t€zone and
comparirc the plasma center to the Honor Health facility. Hs was also concemed about
the admission by Biolib hat it was @ncemed about the square botage issue and
wanted the rezoning for that re6on. lb hoped the Council would consider opposing the
item.
Jen OEines, a Sahuaro reskjent, said she ortned prope0 near the proposed site and
rrver reoEived any information about it She said most of he fobs created would be
manamum wage jobs. She asked if there was going to be sales tax r€venue generated
and if the proieot would ewn help Glendale. She was conoemed about potential drug
traffc in the neighbofiood. She said the constituents urere not in favor of the project.
Rodica Barteb, a Glendale r$ident, asked where the people who were tumed away fiorr
the proposed plasma oenter would go. She was oonoemed and said it was not
something residents wanted in their backyard.
James Deibler, a Phoenix residEnt said it was not a good idee to put the plasma center
near a neighbofiood. lt would bdng drugs, proporty thefi and other crime into the area.
CrUo'Gtortuo P'o.tt Pdfit ttonrnMlul
City Council teetng manu!3s - Flnsl January 10,m17
He asked the Council to keep fieir promise to fie neighborhood and not rezone the
property.
Mayor Vtdeiers said he had speaker cards ftom several citizens who ditl not wbh to
speak. The bllowing persons indicated they were opposed to ilre item: Mlchelle
tAbndler, Bdan \Ahlsh, Laurie Sharp, Tom Sharp, Purdy Hart, and Krystle Goolsby. He
said Sheri Straehli did not wish to speak, but did not indicate whether she was opposed or
in favor of the item.
Nathan Miller, a Sahuaro reskJent purcfiased has home in 1997, and he was wonied
about the impact of the business on the neighborhood. tle didnt have a problem with any
of the medical buildings that had gone up recenily in his area but tris was not a medical
building. He spoke about researcfi he did about the location of plavna clinics and the
impac.t it had on nearby neQhborhoods. He said the Planning Commission did not ask
about crime rates near the exislilrg plasma oenters. The business was not compatible
wih the rnighborhood and asked the Council to vots against the item.
Joy, a Sahuaro resident, was @ncemed about the plasma oenter. She sakl she got to
know the homelEss in Glendale and said many of them were bused in fiom other strates.
She said this was a groMh of drug issue within the Crty. She sald the plasma center
was an added bature to keep fie drug addicted hera in the City.
\Mlliam Schmldt, a Sahuaro resldent, had been a crime victim in his neighborhood. He
had also been approached by homeless p€ople on his street. He didnt want to see the
plasma center in his nebhborhood.
Linda Corley, a Sahuaro resident, sail the clientele of the plasma oenter r,€re not like the
people in the nephborhood. They were usually drug addicts and the homelees.
Jason Harder, a licensed probssional engineer, represented the development company
ard ormership group br the proiect. He said Biolib had Uied to address the
neighborhood issues. He said the rezorr was to address the 5,000 square bot
requirement of medical fimr space and tte problems that could arise in the future if
requircments cfianged or were interpreted difierently. ile said lhis item was purely br
clarification so they didnt run into problems in the firture.
Councilmember Tolmachofi asked Mr. Froke if he had ever had the expedence of a
business being shut down after it had opened because of an issue described by Mr.
Harder.
Mr. Froke said he didn't belierc that had ever happened.
Councilmember Tumer saad he had a question about BioLib's smoking policy.
Ms. Frye said smoking was not allored on the premises and signs w€re posted
accordingly. Ms. Frye also clarified the comments made about cash. She eaid donors
vuere @mpensated wih a debit card and no cash was kept on the premises. She said
the donors were utilizing that money at the gas stations and grooery stores and it could
average between $2 and $3 million.
Councilmember Clark asked if the oommercial ofroe zoning would allow a 5,000 square
fuot commercialoffce on that site.
Mr. Froke said that was coned.
Cwo'G''ltfrla P.8al2 Prtuttcd on ln&ml?
Clty Council teetng tlnuteg. Flnal January 10,ml7
councilmember clark asked a guestion about the 5,000 foot rcquirement and
requirements for buildings wih medical use. She commented on the inbrmation provkled
by Mr. Harder and asked if the entire building, which was larger than 5,000 square bet,
tied to medical use and supporting saMces of that medical use. She asked if that
addifional area was counted as part of the building.
Mr. Froke said an argum€nt oould be made based on Mr. Harder's example. He provided
an example of another medical building that had waiffng areas, storag€ areas and other
parts of the facilig whictr mpht or might not be oomHered medical use.
Councilmember Claft asked if thoee areas were consirJered part of the medical envelope
of that building.
Mr. Froke said ooned.
Councilmember Clark said those areas were all in support of providing medical seMces.
Mr. Froke agreed.
Councilmember Tumer said he asked about smoking on tfie property a lbw minutes ago
because smoking was usually not allowed and it pushed the srnoking to the perimeter of
the properties, whir*t became an issue the nebhbors had to deal wiur. He asked if it
would be possibb to requirc a stipulation to provide a designated vnokiqg area wi[r
shade and seating available, to discourage a smoking nuisance near the neehborhood.
Mr. Froke said he had seen that scenario occur p€nlonally on several occasions. He
said typically, those types of stipulations werent included on site plans, but it dirlnt
mean it couldnt be done. He said it sounded like it might be a BioLib poticy viotation.
Councilmember Tumer was oonoerngd about that and it seemed to be a recuning issrr.
Mayor lA/eiers suggesbd asking BioUb if trey would consider sucfi a stipulation.
Ms. Frye said she would have to speak wih o€ oorporab offioe. she was more than
willing to pose the qu€etion but said providing a smoking area might en@urage unwanted
penrons fiom loitering on the propefiy.
Councilmember Tolmachoff asked if tlte Crty had any medical facalifes where the exam
room was not consider€d part of the medical space.
Mr. Froke said Glendale had three hospitals which were In diftrent zonang districts. He
said each would have gone through a similar process. He was unable to answer
Councilmember Tolmachoffs question.
Councilmember Tolmachofi salt that s€em€d to be fie heart of the issua here and an
exam roorn should be oonsklEred partof the medicalspaoe.
Mr. Harder saad exam roorng could possibly be included as part of the medical spaoe,
which was why he wanted to go through the rezoning process. He requested the
Council vote in Evor of the rezoning so the building could be added to thE community and
not worry about where the line was drann as to specific usage of the square botage.
MayorlAbiers closed the public headng.
Crtyo'Gtcttd',o P'oatt PrrnfronlaumtT
Clty Council teetng tlnuba. Flnel January 10,2017
Moe Mayor Hugh asked lf the Clerk needed to read the ordinanoe.
Ms. Borer sakJ she had previously read the ordinance by tiUe.
Vice Mayor Hugh made a motion, s€conded by Councilmember Clark, to approw
Ordinane No. 017-01.
Councilmember Clark said it was a parhership between neighborhoods, businesses and
golemment and wlren more weQht was given to one, the system became dysfunclional.
She said the notification requirements should be revised to include more homes, as most
of the neQhborhood had no idea what was going on. She said a general office zoning
designation was too intense to be adjaoent to a neighborhood. She was very conoemed
about the quantity of people visiting that site every day. She blt everything supported the
medical adivities in hat building and the entire building was providing m€dical servi€s to
the oommunig. She could not support the fecility at over 16,000 squar€ bet and the
number of visits to the building.
Councilmember Malnar thanked Ms. Frye and her staff br providing inbmation as
reqrcsted, and the community br coming out and shorting their conoem about the issue.
He said there was a Council item of special Intercst outstanding regarding looking at the
s(x).bot notification requirement. lle said the petition signatures he reoeiwd shored him
that the community strongly opposed the ltem. He wouts stand behind the constitlents
that elecled ham and requested Council vote no on the item.
Councilmember Aldama said he would be roting nay. He said the siJnatures on the
petitions he rcceived were ftom that exaci community. lf he had the opportuntty to go
back in tirre, he would adamanfly oppoee the type of zoning that occuned just south of
the Crty Hall building, as that zoning decimated the community that still existed. He
eplained that community lacked resouroes and support ftom a City that couldnt help it
because of the zoning. The proposed facility under diecussion was very dose to homes,
scfiools and parks and he was very conennd about the efiects the zoning would have on
the nearby properties. He knew firsthand houv light industial zoning could impact
residential neighbofioods. He supported the work of sAff and the Planning Commission
as they worked striclly on land use.
Councilmember Tohracfioff thanked the community br coming out to speak on the issue.
She sair! she had a responsibili$ to protect the neQhbohoods and she wodd be voting
nay on this issrc.
Councilmember Tumer would like stafi to be mindful of the smoking problem at the
medical buildings. He sakJ he had to keep in mind this was.a land use case and was not
specific to the tenant, BioLib. He appreciabd lhe comments fiom the community, and
said his r€search indicated no incrsase in crime n€ar th€ plasrna oenter at 51st Avenue
and Northem. lt was a confoming use under the exlsting zoning and he was
sympathetic to Mr. Harde/s position about what might happen under a difiarent anspedor
and they vrere valkj conoems, but hey were not ovenrhelming. Councilmember Tumer
said the land was zoned properly for the deloloper's use at this time and he was nol
compelled to cfiange the zoning wtpn the zoning on the property w* adequate br the
use propo€€d. HE said he was voting no.
Vica Mayor Hugh said Council had rEad all the letters and emails it had received and
appreciabd all the petition signatures. He thanked the resktents br coming tonight and
he was voting nay.
Cftyo/Abrffi.Frt rl Prln6oatnAzUT
Glty Council teedng tlnulel - Flnal January 70,2017
ORDTNANCES
16-67117.
Mayor Wbiers said this was not that diffcult of a decision, but the business could open
up if it wanted to in a smaller fadlity. HE sald it chose to go bbger and that seemed to
be the issrc and he hoped it could find a plaoe that was more receptiw to the business.
lle believed not everyone who donated plasma was a bad pefson and he was conoemed
about those who needed thoee blood producis. He said the Council r€pr€sented the
citizens and they had oveNhelming told them hor they blt. He sald he was voting no on
the issue.
A moton rvar made by Vlce teyor Hugh, $conded by Councilmember Clark,
ttat thb agenda ibm be apprcved. The motion frlled by the following vote:
Nay: 7 - Mayor \Afeiers, Vice Mayor Hugh, Councilmember Aldama, Councilmember Clark,
Councilmember Malnar, Councilmember Tolmadroff, and Councilmember Tumer
The Crty Council recessed at 8:50 p.m.
The City Council reconvened at 9:00 p.m.
ORDINANCE NO. (9^1742
AN ORDINANCE OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GLENDALE,
MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA, AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF
AN IRRIGATION EASEMENT IN FAVOR OF SALT RIVER PROJECT
AGRICULTUML IMPROVEMENT AND POVVER DISTRICT LOCATED
ON DISCOVERY DRIVE VVEST OF 79TH AVENUE; DIRECTING THE
CITY CLERK TO RECORD A CERTIFIED COPY OF THIS ORDINANCE;
AND DECLARING AN EMERGENCY.
StaffContact Jack Friedline, Director, Public Works
Ms. Bower read Ordinanoe No. 017-02.
Mr. Fdedline said tfp item was a Fquest to adopt an ordinance granting a new inigation
e$ement to Salt River Project (SRP) an the Discovery Ddrre alpnment west of 79th
Avenue, and decladng an emergency to provtle for the cfianges to be efieclive January
11,2017, which ooodinated wih the SRP dry up. SRp was gcing to pipe an open
inigation ditcft south of Discovery Scfiool, whicfr would be located in the Discovery Drive
alignment. SRP was regueeting an inigation easement in order to construct the structure
within the Discovery Drive right-of-way. Staff recommended granting the inigation
eas€rnent.
Mayor lA/eiers asked if this was oonsider€d an emergency because of the dry up.
Mr. Bailey said when an ordinance was pass€d as an emergency, il was eftctirre
immediately.
Councilmember Tumer asked if time was of the essence.
Mr. Friedline said yes itwas because itwas perceiwd as a sabty issue brthe scfrool.
Clty0'C'o''[t/,o F|g. t,Prffi.ttot rnU2UT
Glty Councll tee0ng tlnulea - Flnal January 10,m17
Councilmember Clark said this was the canal dry up period br this sirJe of tfre valley and
SRP would like to get this ditch cowrcd bebre inigation water begins f,owing again.
Mayor $Giers said that was why he asked if it was because of the dry up.
Councilmember Tumer asked if this was sor€thing they were trying to acoomplish dudng
the dry up period.
Mr. Friedline said yes itwas.
Councilmember Tumer was not in favor of dedaring an emergency to preclude the public
ftorn doing a rebrendum and he did not want items to @me bebre Council that were not
timely.
Mr. Bailey said it was not to prohibit anyorr from participating. lf stafi didnt declare an
etnergency, they had to wait 30 days until the ordinance was efiEctive, and they would
lose the window to perform the work dudng tlte dry up season.
Councilmember Tumer would like to know up ftont $'hat the €mergEncy was and agreed it
was important to gtst that done during the dry up.
Mayor tA/eiers said he blt the same way, but didn't like the word "emergency."
A modon war mde by Gouncilmember Glerk, ceconded by Vlce tayor Hugh,
fi.tfiL agenda lbm be eppmved. The moton carded by the followlng vo!.:
Aye: 7 ' Mayor lrt&iers, Me Mayor Hr€h, Councilmember Aldama, Councilmember Clark,
Gouncilmember Malnar, Councilmember Tolmachoff, and Coundlmember Tumer
16-672 oRD|NANCE NO. 017-03
AN ORDINANCE OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GLENDALE,
MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA, AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF A
WARRANTY DEED FOR RIGHT OF WAY LOCATED AT THE
NORTH\A/EST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF 59TH AND
NORTHERN AVENUES AND DIRECTING THE CIW CLERK TO
RECORD A CERTIFIED COPY OF THIS ORDINANCE.
Staff Contact Jack Friedline, Director, Public Works
Ms. Borer read Ordinance No. 017{3.
Mr. Fdedline said the item was a reguest to adopt an ordinance acoepting a dghtof-way
along southbound 59ttt Avenue near Norfiem Avenue and along upslbound North€m
AvEnue west of 59th Avenue. Frances and sons, LLc, the orner of a proposed
commercial development at the nortlmast comer of 59ilr Avenue and Northem Awnue
was required to aonstruct street improvements to meet cun€nt street atterial design
tequirements. Frances and Sons, [lC had agreed to dedicate additional dghtof-way to
maintain this portion. The execution of the wananty deed allowed the City to incorporate
upgrade of the signal system at the intersection, which included f,ashing yellow left tum
si;nals on all bur lanes of the inters€ctlon and cornplied wih the timeline br an ADOT
grant. Staff recornmended acepting the additional rightof-way along 59th Avenue and
Northem Avenue.
Councilmember Tumer thanked Mr. Frances br expediting the dedication in a timely
18.
CtUoJGbm,/o W.rc Prftttodon fi2AiIOt7
City Council teetng lllnutec - Flnel Januaty 10,2017
19.
manner to improve sabty at that intersection.
A modon war mrde by CouncilmemberTurner, eeconded by Councllmember
Tolmachofi, thatthie agenda ilam be apprcved. Tte moton caried by the
following vote:
Aye: 7 ' MayorttGiers, Moe Mayor Hugh, CouncilmemberAldama, CouncilmemberClark,
Councilmember Malnar, Councilmember Tolmachoff, and Councilmember Tumer
16-673 oRD|NANCE NO. O17-U
AN ORDINANCE OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GLENDALE,
MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA, AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF
AN IRRIGATION EASEMENT IN FAVOR OF SALT RIVER PROJECT
AGRICULTURAL IMPROVEMENT AND PO\A'ER DISTRICT LOCATED
ON 59TH AND OLIVE AVENUE INTERSECTION AND DIRECTING THE
CIW CLERK TO RECORD A CERTIFIED COPY OF THIS ORDINANCE
AND SAID EASEMENTAND DECLARINGAN EMERGENCY.
Staff Contract Jack Friedline, Director, Public Works
Ms. Bouer read Ordinanoe No. 017-04.
Mr. Friedline said the item was a request to adopt an ordinance granting an lrigation
easemeril in favor of Salt Rirrer Prctiecl (SRP) at the 59th Avenue and Olive Avenue
intersec'tion and declaring an eme€ency with reblence to time being of essenca in
construding the inigation structure dudng SRP's seasonal dry up and to provide br the
changes to be efieclive on January 11, 2017. The City woutd be comtructing bus
pullouts and right tum lanes wihin the right-of-way in order to increase travel capacity at
the intersedion in the future. To construct the improrements, SRP must upgrade their
piping and required fie Clty to provid,e a new inigation easement to maintain and proted
its facilities. Strafi recommended granting the inpation easement and tre City would be
able to construct a bus pullout and right tum lans over the SRP inigation facilities.
A mo0on wae mede by Councllmember Tolmachoff, aeconded by
Councilmember Glark, thatthls agenda lbm be approved. lhe modon carled by
the followlng vob:
Aye: 7 ' Mayor tA/biers, Mce Mayor Hugh, Courrilmember Aldama, Councilmember Clark,
Councilmember Malnar, Councilmember Tolmachofi, and Councilmember Tumer
NEWBUSINESS
16-56920.COUNCIL SELECTION OF VICE MAYOR
Staff Contact Brent Stoddard, Director, Public Afiairs
Councilmember Malnar made a motion, s€conded by Councilmember Clark, to norninate
lan Hugh as Mce Mayor.
Councilmember Tumer satJ he had peviously raised the question of rotating the position
of Moe Mayor, to gave all Councilmembers the opportunity to serye in that role. He said
several r€portec thought he was campaQning for the position. He explained that was not
his intent. He just wanted the Council to take a look at the policy whicfi he betie\€d hed
been detimental to Councils an the past and wanted to pr€vent that ftom happening
again. He asked the Council to keep an open mind and perhaps address the issue in the
near frrture.
CfryolAt tri/PqotT PtWmrnmntT
City Gouncil lleetng tlnutee. Flnal January 10,2017
Councilmember Clark agreed with Councilmember Turner's remarks and sairJ e\Eryone
had the necessary qualifications to s€ne as Vioe Mayor. She sakl there had never been
a rotating system lo serve as Mce Mayor in the history of the ciry. She said the person
serving as Moe Mayor had to enfoy the trust of everyone on the Council and Moe Mayor
Hugh had uprked hard to maintain good relationships wifr gveryone on the Council. She
said they had to be careful of the consequences of estrablishing a system withorit glving
any thought to the intangibles.
Councilmember Aldama said revoMng the posiUon should come voluntarily and
encouraged the Council to di\€rsafy the position as it was ceremonial. He blt e\€ry one
of his colleagues wer€ qualiied br the poeition.
Gouncilmember Tumer sakJ he wasnt sure that the Council never had a polacy that
rotated the tiUe of Moe Mayor among the Councilmembers, and saad there were other
cities across the valley which selected a Mce Mayor in various ways. He said there
maght be a betterway to do it
A moton wae made by Councihnember llalnar, ceconded by Councllmember
Clerk, drat $is egenda item be approved. The moton canled by 0re followlng
volo:
Aye: 7 ' MayorlAteiers. Mce Mayor Hugh, CouncilmemberAldama, Councilmember Clark,
Councilmember Malnar, Councilmember Tolmachofi, and Councilmember Tumer
REQUEST FOR FUTURE WOR|GHOP AND EXECUTTVE SESSTON
A moton wae mede by l/lce tayor Hugh, oconded by Gouncllmember Chrlq to
hold the next togularly rcheduled Clty Councll Workehop on Tuerday, Janury
17,m17 at l:30 p.m.In $e Cl,ty CouncllChamber:, !o be followed by an
Erecuffve Seaeion punuant to A.R.S. 3E431.03. The moton canled by the
followlng vote:
Aye: 7 ' Mayor Weiers, Vioe Mayor Hugh, CourrilmemberAldama, Councilmember Clark,
Councilmember Malnar, Councilmember Tolmachofi and Councilmember Tumer
COUNCIT COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS
Councilmember Aldama thanked the Polioe Department for their work in the community.
In Odober of 2016, Offioer Lacay Tolbert submitted a request to the Channel 3 surprise
squad. The children from the Roots Program in the Oootillo Districn, reoeircd many gifts
and elecffonics they might never have received. He thanked fficar Tolbert and the
Police Departnent br engaging in the oommunity.
councifmember claft announced a distict meeting on Thursday, February 2, 2017 at
Desert Mirage Elementary school, 8600 w. Maryhnd Avenue. she enoouragod everyone
to saVe the date to attend the meeting.
Councilmember Malnar thanked reskJents of the Sahuaro District who came out tonight
as well as those residents who had volunteered to be on the Sahuaro Districi Advisory
Committee. Another meeting would be held on January 26th and emails would be going
out. He said anyorr trom the distict was eligible to be on the cornmittee.
Councilmember Tumer said the 54th Annual Juried Arb Shor was on display in the
gallery at sahuaro Ranch Park daily ftom 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. The shor ran through
January 29th. He encouragod e\€ryone to coflie out and enjoy the art. He also sairj the
CtyofGbllxi/,e tue.1t Prffiont/2A4Ut
City Council teetng tinuter. Flnal Januaty 10,m17
ADIOURNMENT
Glendale Downtown Farmer's Market was on the 2nd and 4th Saturday of each month
ftom 8 a.m. to noon. He said the location was moving to the parking lot at 59h and
Myrth.
Councilmember Tolmadrofi invited all Glendale residents to a shred event hosted by
Councilmember Tolmachoff and Councilmember Malnar on February 11th from 8a.m. to
11a.m. Donations were limited to live banker boxes and when tre trucks $ere full, fF
event would be concluded. The event would be held at the Foothills Library pafiing lot.
Mce Mayor Hugh thanked everyon€ for their rote tonight.
Mayor lAbiers sakt about 300 people were bd at the Wings of Pere held by Louise
Pennitr and the Knights of Columbus. He challenged the entire Council to go down as a
group one day and serve lunch. lle said they really helped the citizens and he would like
to see them get some hefp fiom the oqanization From the Heart lle thankod €veryo,re
br attending the meeting.
The Cig Counciladjoumed at9:26 p.m.
I hereby certify that the foregoing minutes are a true and coneci
copy of the minubs of the meeting of the Glendale City Council
of Gfendale, Arizona, held on the 10th day of January, 2017. a
further oertifo that the meeting was duly called and held and
that a quorum was present.
4(ft|Dared rhisr/i/ day ot {rt^JUAfZl ,2017.
C/'yolC/rlrfrL Fte.rg Ptturrdmil2aiM?