HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - Minutes - Community Development Advisory Commission - Meeting Date: 11/20/2014 MINUTES
CITY OF GLENDALE
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
GLENDALE CITY HALL—ROOM B-3
5850 W. GLENDALE AVENUE
Thursday,November 20,2014
6:30 p.m.
MEMBERS PRESENT: Pattie Johnston, Vice Chair
Sue Pederson
Dorlisa Dvorak
Ronald Jauregui
Matthew Versluis
Chuck Jared
Marcellous Sanders
Sharyn Nesbitt
MEMBERS ABSENT: Cherie Hudson, Chair
Cathy Cheshier
John Torres
STAFF PRESENT: Charyn Palmisano, Revitalization Supervisor
Elaine Adamczyk, Community Housing Manager
Fred Abraham, Public Housing Maintenance Supervisor
Mona Francis, Revitalization Supervisor
Elizabeth Garcia, Revitalization Coordinator
Chris Plummer, ASK Development Solutions, Inc.
Janet Plummer, ASK Development Solutions, Inc.
Call to Order
Vice Chair Johnston called the meeting to order at 6:30 p.m.
II. Roll Call
Vice Chair Johnston conducted roll call.
III. Minutes
Committee-member Jared motioned to approve the October 16, 2014 meeting minutes as written.
Committee-member Sanders made the second. The motion passed 8—0.
IV. Business from the Floor
None.
V. Public Hearing: FY2015-2019 Consolidated Plan and Annual Action Plan
Mr. Plummer, consultant to the City of Glendale, gave an overview of the process of the Consolidated
Plan and Annual Action Plan and elicited comments regarding existing priorities, goals and objectives.
Minutes of the Community Development Advisory Committee
November 20,2014
Page 2
Five Year Consolidated Plan
o HUD requires each entitlement jurisdiction to submit a Consolidated Plan every five years. The
last one done was 2010 - 2014.
o A tool to identify a city's Housing and Community Development (HCD) needs, priorities and
strategies
o A tool to stipulate how federal funds will be allocated
o A collaborative process with opportunity for citizen participation and creating a unified
community vision
o Opportunity to shape the various HCD programs into effective, coordinated neighborhood and
HCD strategies
o To reduce duplication of effort at the local level
o The three basic goals of the plan are:
• Provision of decent housing
• Creation of a suitable living environment
• Expansion of economic opportunities
o The process consists of:
• Consultation with public and private agencies and public participation
• Review City planning documents, conduct research and analyze data
• Conduct a Housing Market Analysis
• Conduct a Needs Assessment
• Develop a Comprehensive Strategic Plan identifying priorities and strategies
• Plan Review Process — including a 30 day period for public comment, then onto City
Council for approval
o The format of the plan will include the following elements:
• Social and economic characteristics
• Assessment of the City's housing and community development needs
• The nature/extent of homelessness and special needs housing
• Housing conditions including lead-based paint
• Establishing priority need areas,program objectives and activities
• A performance measurement system to indicate progress
• The local institutional structure for Plan delivery
• Citizen participation plan and process
• An anti-displacement and relocation plan
• Impediments to fair housing choice and fair housing planning
• Barriers to affordable housing
• Possible use of incentives
Annual Action Plan—How the City Will Spend CDBG Funds
o Based on Consolidated Plan priorities and needs
o Expected resources
o Annual goals and objectives
o List of projects/award recommendations
o Geographic priorities
o Affordable housing
o Public housing, homeless and social needs
o Housing Opportunities for Persons With Aids (HOPWA)
o Barriers to affordable housing
o Program specific requirements
Minutes of the Community Development Advisory Committee
November 20,2014
Page 3
Eligible Activities
o CDBG
■ Acquisition and Disposition
• Public Facilities and Improvements
• Clearance and Demolition
• Public services
■ Housing Rehabilitation
• Homeownership Assistance
• Planning and Administration
o HOME
• Homeownership and Rental Housing
• CHDO
o ESG
■ Emergency shelter and Rapid Rehousing
Current Priorities
o CDBG
o Public Services
• Seniors and Youth
• Persons with disabilities
• Homelessness prevention
• Domestic Violence
• General: food bank, legal services
o Public facilities rehabilitation
o Owner occupied rehabilitation
o Emergency assistance
o HOME
• Owner Occupied Rehabilitation
• New Construction of Housing (homebuyer)
o ESG
• Rapid rehousing
• Homeless prevention
• Shelter operations (CASS in Phoenix)
Mr. Plummer asked if the Committee was in agreement with the objective of the Plan. Vice Chair
wondered if there were any changes to the objectives from last year. Ms. Palmisano confirmed that the
objectives were consistent with Council priorities. All Committee-members were in agreement with the
objectives presented.
Committee-member Pederson felt all objectives were equally dire. Committee-member Jared stressed
homelessness as a priority and Committee-member Saunders agreed.
Committee-member Juaregui asked if Habitat for Humanity is the only contractor working with the City
for acquisition/rehab for CDBG. Ms. Palmisano stated that the department does put out an RFP and
Chicanos Por La Causa attended an orientation, but did not apply.
Ms. Francis explained the process of the public notice for the CDBG workshop and the grant
applications.
Minutes of the Community Development Advisory Committee
November 20,2014
Page 4
Mr. Plummer stated that a resident survey regarding the Five Year Consolidated Plan would be
distributed to the Committee-members for completion.
Vice Chair Johnston opened the floor to a Public Hearing for comments on the 2015-2019
Consolidated Plan and Annual Action Plan.
No comments were made.
Vice Chair Johnston closed the floor to a Public Hearing for comments.
VI. Xeriscaping Project at Community Housing
Ms. Adamczyk gave an overview of the xeriscaping at Cholla Vista and Lamar Homes Public Housing
Complexes. Ms. Adamczyk thanked the Committee for the recommendation and receipt of project
funding in the amount of $114,000 via a 2013-14 CDBG grant. Ms. Adamczyk also introduced Mr.
Abraham, who was present for questions and clarification.
Ms. Adamczyk provided details of the project at Cholla Vista, highlights include the following:
• There are 34 apartments.
• All aging and damaged landscaping and grass will be removed and will be replaced with water-
wise trees, bushes, shrubs and decomposed granite.
• Old and broken sprinkler lines will be repaired/replaced/redirected as necessary.
• Current courtyard sidewalks and picnic tables will be removed and replaced with ADA
compliant walkways and accessible picnic tables.
Ms. Adamczyk provided details of the project at Lamar Homes, highlights include the following
information:
• There are 51 apartments.
• Small grass areas will be removed and replaced with decomposed granite.
Ms. Adamczyk announced that the project will improve the quality of life of public housing residents
and continue the City's efforts to save water. Ms. Adamczyk stated that the project will realize an
estimated sprinkler system water savings of 60%.
Ms. Adamczyk stated that on November 24th, Council will approve the contract for the project to be
awarded to Sunburst Landscaping. Ms. Adamczyk stated that this contractor has worked with the City
before and has a very good track record.
Vice Chair Johnston asked if some of the picnic tables could be reused elsewhere. Mr. Abraham replied
in the positive and stated that staff will re-use/re-purpose all possible items. Mr. Abraham noted that
pictures of the completed project will be presented at a future Committee meeting.
VII. Point In Time MAG Homeless Count
Ms. Palmisano briefed the Committee on the Maricopa Association of Governments (MAG) Point in
Time count of the homeless population which will be held on January 27, 2015 from 5:30 a.m. to 12:00
p.m. Ms. Palmisano noted the following:
Minutes of the Community Development Advisory Committee
November 20,2014
Page 5
• The Point In Time is a one night street and shelter count to determine the number of homeless in
Maricopa County at a given point in time.
• Staff will go out in groups to perform the count. Staff members volunteer to participate.
• This count is required for the City to continue to receive HUD federal funding for homeless
assistance. The City participates via the MAG Continuum of Care Regional Committee on
Homelessness. Other valley cities in the MAG Continuum of Care will perform their counts on
the same day as well.
Ms. Palmisano stated that she participated in the Point In Time Count in the past and found it to be very
eye-opening. Mr. Abraham added that the Police Department is also a great resource for the Point In
Time count as the department keeps abreast of where the homeless are concentrated.
Ms. Palmisano estimated that 30-40 homeless people were identified in the last count in which she
participated. Ms. Palmisano noted that this is a relatively low count compared to other cities.
Committee-member Sanders stated that it can be hard to get an accurate count because some of the
homeless might try to avoid being seen and/or counted. Ms. Palmisano agreed.
Committee-members noted areas whereby they have seen some homeless people in need.
Committee-member Nesbit asked if staff will obtain more detailed information on those counted. Ms.
Palmisano stated that the police do collect details on the homeless in their beats and there is also an
internal task force in place to address issues with homelessness.
VIII. Staff Updates
Staff provided an update to the Committee on relevant and recent department activities.
Ms. Adamczyk announced that the City received the following inspection scores for Public Housing.
• 98% - Public Housing Assessment System (PHAS) score for Public Housing, rating the Glendale
Public Housing program as HUD High Performer.
• 95.6% - Physical Inspection score for the three public housing properties, including the
administrative buildings.
Ms. Adamczyk noted that following statistics for Public Housing:
• There are 155 families assisted through the Glendale Public Housing rental assistance program,
living in three rental communities.
• There are 367 total persons receiving assistance through the Public Housing program, of which there
are 167 children under the age of 18. These children comprise 46% of all persons receiving
assistance through Public Housing.
• There were 2,659 Public Housing work orders issued by the receptionist and completed by the
Public Housing Maintenance team this year.
Minutes of the Community Development Advisory Committee
November 20,2014
Page 6
• The average number of days to complete a routine work order was 4.58 days.
• There were 373 emergency work orders completed by the Public Housing Maintenance team.
• The average time to complete an emergency work order was 3.36 hours, far exceeding HUD's 24
hour requirement
• There were 736 Public Housing unit inspections scheduled and completed for the 155 families.
Ms. Adamczyk noted the following statistics for Public Housing and the Section 8 Voucher Program:
• There were 11,000 telephone calls answered by the front reception team. This does not include calls
that went directly to other staff.
• There were 9,000 walk-in visitors to the Housing administrative building, greeted by the front desk
team or other staff.
• There were 4,640 family reports generated and submitted to HUD for file actions relating to the
1,555 families in our programs. These reports reflect changes in subsidy based on changes to family
status.
• There is zero tolerance for criminal activity. Our success is due to our ongoing partnership with
Glendale PD and the CAT team assigned to our location.
Ms. Adamczyk stressed that the exceptional HUD inspection scores and program statistics point to the quality
of the housing units, staff and program service.
Ms. Palmisano distributed a flyer announcing the 3rd Annual Glendale Family Health and Resource Fair to be
held on Saturday, November 22nd from 9:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. at the Glendale Civic Center. There will be
information on community resources, onsite enrollments for various assistance programs and free medical
screenings.
Vice Chair Johnston thanked staff for all the hard work done over the month and the past year.
IX. Committee Comments and Suggestions
Committee-member Sanders stated that he assisted a friend from the police department deliver a food
box to a woman in need and the experience was both heartbreaking and heartwarming at the same time.
Committee-member Nesbit asked for a copy of Mr. Plummer's Power Point presentation. Committee-
member Nesbit asked how the Housing Discrimination Survey was advertised. Mr. Plummer explained
that the survey was disseminated to and via various public agencies, landlords, City website, electronic
and printed advertising and in the city water bill.
X. Adjournment
Minutes of the Community Development Advisory Committee
November 20,2014
Page 7
Committee-member Jared motioned to adjourn at 7:50 p.m. Vice Chair Johnston made the
second. The motion passed 8—0.
The next meeting is December 1St at 6:30 p.m. in Council Chambers at City Hall. CDAC will hear
presentations from half of the public services applicants at this meeting.
Respectfully submitted,
Recording Secretary
Denise Kazmierczak