HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - Minutes - Aviation Advisory Commission - Meeting Date: 11/9/2011 MINUTES
AVIATION ADVISORY COMMISSION
GLENDALE MUNICIPAL AIRPORT
6801 N GLEN HARBOR BLVD - SUITE 201
GLENDALE, ARIZONA 85307
AIRPORT CONFERENCE ROOM
NOVEMBER 9,2011
7:00 P.M.
I. CALL TO ORDER
The meeting was called to order by Chair Ron Cohoe with the following
Commissioners present: Vice-Chair Carl Duggins, Bill Kelly, Victoria Rogen,
Leslie Sheeler, Joe Cable and Robert Irons.
Also present were Walter Fix, Interim Airport Manager; Jamsheed Mehta, City of
Glendale Executive Director of Transportation Services; Bill Gillies, Luke Air
Force Base; Basil Allen, Air Traffic Control Tower; Clare Pryke, Valley Aviation
Services; Tito Suazo, Aerosim Aviation
II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF THE PREVIOUS MEETING
Commissioner Irons motioned to approve the October 12, 2011 meeting
minutes as written. Commissioner Kelly made the second. The motion
passed 7 - 0.
III. REQUEST FOR CONTINUANCE OR WITHDRAWL OF ITEMS
None.
IV. AIRPORT BUSINESS
The following items were addressed.
1. Airport Restaurant
Mr. Fix stated that the proposed Airport Restaurant Lease Agreement with Left
Seat West at Glendale will be presented to Mayor and Council on November 22,
2011.
Mr. Fix explained that the previous airport restaurant proprietor vacated the
building in January 2011 and an RFP was issued soon afterward for a
replacement. Mr. Fix stated that only one response was received and
subsequently reviewed and approved by the Transportation Department and
Airport Staff. This was the proposal from Left Seat West at Glendale. Mr. Fix
commented that there is also a Left Seat at Phoenix Sky Harbor which has been
1
serving customers for the past seven years and thus the proprietor has experience
in the airport restaurant arena.
Mr. Fix read the terms of the lease with the Glendale Municipal Airport as
follows:
• The lease will be for five years, with an additional nine years, renewable
in three-year increments.
• The rent for the first month will be 1% of the gross receipts increasing by
1% each month until the fifth month.
• Thereafter, the rent will be $800 per month or 6% of the gross receipts,
whichever is greater until the completion of the first year of the lease.
• For the second year, the rent will be $1,000 per month or 6% of the gross
receipts, whichever is greater.
• For the third through fifth year of the lease, the rent will be $1,200 per
month or 6% of the gross receipts, whichever is greater.
• Left Seat West will be responsible for all utility services provided to Suite
104 and the patio seating.
• Specific maintenance and warranty agreements are included in the lease as
well.
Chair Cohoe wondered if Left Seat would use the same decor for the Glendale
location as is used in the Sky Harbor location. Mr. Fix was not aware of the plans
for decor at this time. Mr. Fix noted that the owners might bring some furniture
over for use at the Glendale location.
Chair Cohoe inquired about signage off of Glendale Avenue and suggested that it
be large enough to drive business to the restaurant. Mr. Fix stated that the City
Planning Department has sign regulations which need to be followed. Mr. Fix
added that the old restaurant did have a placard sign near the Airport entryway
monument to advertise for business.
Commissioner Rogen inquired as to the estimated opening of the restaurant. Mr.
Fix stated that the restaurant owners would like to open in December. Mr. Fix
stated that the Health Department would be out to the location during this week.
Mr. Fix announced that the planned hours during the week are 6:00 a.m. to 2:00
p.m. with breakfast and lunch available at all times.
Commissioner Sheeler suggested an announcement be placed in the District
Newsletters. Mr. Fix will follow through with the suggestion.
Commissioner Rogen asked if the restaurant proprietor had an inventory list of the
current furniture available. Mr. Fix replied in the positive and added that the
proprietor may bring in some of his own furniture as well. Mr. Fix will ensure
that there is an accounting of all City furniture.
2
Chair Cohoe commented that Left Seat is well-established and has a good
reputation at Sky Harbor.
Mr. Gillies stressed the importance of quick service at the restaurant, especially
for a lunch hour.
Commissioner Duggins motioned to recommend Council approval of the
Airport Restaurant Lease with Left Seat West at Glendale. Commissioner
Rogen made the second. The motion passed 7 - 0.
2. Update on FAA and the Corrective Action Plan
Mr. Fix stated that Mr. Tony Garcia came out to Glendale October 25th and 26`h to
review the administrative procedures and the progress of the Corrective Action
Plan. Mr. Fix commented that unfortunately Mr. Garcia could not coordinate his
trip to coincide with a Commission meeting.
Mr. Fix also reviewed the Airport Layout Plan with Mr. Garcia and took Mr.
Garcia on a tour of the taxiway ramps and the entire airport.
Mr. Fix noted on that on the evening of October 25`h, Mr. Garcia and Mr. Fix met
in the terminal lobby with members of the airport businesses and the tenants. Mr.
Fix stated that Mr. Garcia was very helpful and answered many of the questions
posed by attendees.
Mr. Fix provided the following update on the Corrective Action Plan:
• The Airport is meeting the FAA milestones.
• The weekly teleconference call with a Washington, DC representative has
continued. During the call, timelines and action plans are discussed.
Mr. Fix stated that last month, there was a question from the Chair regarding the
hangar count for compliance and non-compliance. Mr. Fix reported that out of
268 hangars, there were 105 Letters of Non-Compliance and the remaining 163
hangars were in overall compliance. Mr. Fix explained that an occupant can
receive of Letter of Non-Compliance and have a very simple resolution, such as
simply removing a non-aeronautical item. Mr. Fix stated that the occupants do
receive a copy of the original inspection sheet.
Mr. Fix explained that a hangar can have minor issues, such as needing a Non-
Smoking sign or repair of a stair defect, but still be in overall compliance. Mr.
Fix stressed that the majority of non-compliance is due to the storage of non-
aeronautical items. Mr. Fix stated that December 1, 2011 is the hard deadline for
removal of non-aeronautical items from the non-compliant hangars. Reminder
letters will be sent as necessary.
3
Chair Cohoe wondered if all hangar inspections were completed. Mr. Fix replied
that all hangar inspections were completed by the end of October deadline.
Commissioner Irons requested clarification of how the hangar inspections and
Corrective Action Plan relate to the lawsuit filed by a hangar occupant. Mr.
Mehta explained that there are two separate issues that stemmed from the lawsuit
by a hangar occupant:
1. The lawsuit in Civil Court whereby a judgment was made and the
complainant was awarded and paid the amount of this judgment by the
City of Glendale.
2. The same complainant contacted the FAA which led to the Part 16
whereby the FAA stated that the Airport failed to comply with certain
Federal Grant Assurances. The FAA prepared the Corrective Action
Plan so that the Airport can correct the issues requiring resolution.
The Airport Layout Plan is part of the Corrective Action Plan (ALP),
wherein aeronautical and non-aeronautical areas must be clearly
detailed.
3. Arizona Airports Association Fall Conference in Gilbert
Mr. Fix noted that he recently attended the Arizona Airports Association Fall
Conference in Gilbert at which there were approximately 150 attendees from all
over the state. Mr. Fix commented that the Conference was very informative and
panel discussions were held on topics such as solar facilities, safety issues and the
grants process.
Commissioner Cable inquired as to how often this Conference is held. Mr. Fix
explained that the Conference is held twice yearly in the Spring and Fall. Mr. Fix
plans on representing the Glendale Airport at the Conference to be held in Tucson
in the Spring.
4. Amendment to the 2004 Airport Rules and Regulations
Mr. Fix announced that on October 25th, City Council approved the amendment to
the 2004 Airport Rules and Regulations. Mr. Fix stated that the cover page was
changed to read "2011 Revised Airport Rules and Regulations" due to the
amendment added. Mr. Fix stated that the newly approved Rules and Regulations
are posted on the Airport website and will be provided by email to the entire
Airport database of contacts such as occupants, tenants and users.
Chair Cohoe commented that a few years ago, the Commission worked on a very
large update of the Rules and Regulations and wondered when those updates
would be considered for approval as well. Mr. Fix replied that he was in
possession of the information and will review the proposed changes. Mr. Fix
commented that one of his goals is that by the end of 2012, the Rules and
Regulations will be revised in regards to minimum operating standards, which
4
also would flow with the changes proposed by the Commission. Mr. Fix
commented that the FAA has strongly suggested that the Airport devise a leasing
policy and this would be an appendix to the minimum operating standards. Mr.
Fix is currently working on a timeline for this project for 2012.
5. Sub-Committee Reports
Chair Cohoe stated that the current Sub-Committees were established at the
beginning of 2011. Chair Cohoe commented that as the Commission learned last
month, the Sub-Committees are subject to the rules of the Open Meeting Law
whereby an agenda must be posted and minutes must be taken and published.
Chair Cohoe wondered if the Commissioners would rather disband the use of
regular Sub-Committees and as major projects or issues arise, the Commission
could either tackle resolution as a whole or establish an ad-hoc Sub-Committee at
that time.
The Commission agreed by consensus to disband the permanent Sub-
Committees, address and take actions as necessary by the Commission as a
whole during regular monthly meetings on previous Sub-Committee issues,
and create an ad-hoc Sub-Committee only when necessity dictates.
Commissioner Rogen wondered if the Sub-Committee topics, such as events,
Commission Outings and Security, could still be reported on by Mr. Fix. It was
agreed that Mr. Fix would include any pertinent or current information on these
topics in the Summary of Current Events section of the agenda as necessary.
V. SUMMARY OF CURRENT EVENTS
Mr. Fix provided an update on current projects at or impacting the airport.
Highlights include the following:
• ADOT's Airport Capital Improvement Project (ACIP) web-based
submittal is up and running after a one-month delay. Mr. Fix just received
his password and will submit the Glendale Airport Five-Year CIP
submitted on the website by November 21, 2011. Mr. Fix stated that CIP
projects include environmental assessments, pavement projects and design
projects.
• Mr. Fix, the FAA and a project consultant discussed Project 20 on a recent
phone conference. Mr. Fix explained that Project 20 is the design of a
blast fence relocation. Mr. Fix noted that one FAA engineer did not want
two sections of the blast fence near Glendale Avenue and wanted the blast
fences completely removed. During the phone call, it was explained to
this engineer that a corporate jet could produce jet blast on Glendale
Avenue without the blast fence. It was agreed during the phone call that
the blast fence would not be removed, but would be relocated to protect
any impact toward Glendale Avenue. The relocation of the blast fence
will be done next Spring. Other Project 20 items that will be completed
5
by the end of 2011 are the ramp markings and the relocation of the wind
sock.
• Mr. Fix reported that operations are up and that take offs and landings
through September 2011 were 18% above those through September 2010.
Chair Cohoe wondered if the on-site schools were providing any increase in
traffic. Mr. Allen replied in the negative, explaining that most traffic is coming
from other airports.
Mr. Allen still thinks last year's operation numbers will be surpassed, but not by
much. Mr. Allen explained that October and November counts were not as
promising. Mr. Gillies inquired about the traffic count. Mr. Allen replied that
traffic is at 82,000 for the year so far as of today. Mr. Allen added that the total
traffic for 2010 was 86,000.
Mr. Gillies inquired as to the busiest time for the Airport. Mr. Allen explained
that the busiest time is Monday through Friday from 8:00 a.m. and 11:00 a.m.
Chair Cohoe distributed a list of local fuel prices to the Commissioners.
Commissioner lions inquired as to the reasons for different fuel prices at different
airports. Chair Cohoe suggested that this would be a good agenda topic for a
future meeting.
VI. CALL TO THE PUBLIC
No business from the floor was presented.
VII. NEW BUSINESS REQUESTS
The following future agenda items were suggested:
• Update on preparations and planning for the 2015 Super Bowl
• Presentation by the new Airport restaurant proprietor
• Presentation on fuel prices
• A report from the FBO on the status of operations
• Discussion of opportunities to increase Airport business
• Information on how other Airports have increased business
• Timeline for revisions to the Rules and Regulations
• Possible Airport events and any City restrictions or limitations on the
types of events that can be held at the Airport
• Land use restrictions at the Airport
VIII. NEXT MEETING TIME
The next Commission meeting will be held at 7:00 p.m., Wednesday, December
14, 2011 on the second floor Conference Room of the Airport Terminal Building
6
located at the Glendale Municipal Airport, 6801 N. Glen Harbor Blvd Suite 201,
Glendale, AZ.
IX. COMMISSION COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS
Chair Cohoe announced that this evening's meeting was the last meeting for
Commissioner Kelly. Chair Cohoe thanked Commissioner Kelly for his five and
a half years of service to the Commission. Commissioner Kelly stated that he has
enjoyed participating and serving on the Commission has been a very educational
experience.
Chair Cohoe noted that next month, there will be a vacant seat on the Commission
and a new Commissioner will be appointed soon.
X. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned by consensus at 8:09 p.m.
The Aviation Advisory Commission Meeting Minutes of November 9, 2011 were
approved at the Commission Meeting of December 14, 2011.
Walter L. Fix
Interim Airport Manager
623-930-2188
7