HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - Minutes - City Council - Meeting Date: 12/16/2009 !i City of Glendale
GLENIDt Council Sustainability Committee
Minutes
November 17, 2009
10:30 a.m. to 11:30 a.m.
Council Chambers Conference Room B-2
Meeting Attendees
Council Sustainability Committee Members
Present were Councilmember/Chairperson David Goulet (Ocotillo District), and Councilmember
Yvonne Knaack (Barrel District).
City Staff Members
Ken Reedy, Deborah Mazoyer, Pam Wertz, Roger Bailey, Rebecca Benna, Larry Broyles, Jon
Froke, Stuart Kent, Doug Kukino, Jo Miller, Bob Manginell, and Marilyn Clark.
I. Approval of Minutes
Chairperson Goulet made a motion to approve the minutes from the October 20, 2009 meeting
as presented. Councilmember Knaack seconded the motion, and the minutes were approved.
II. Revised Mission Statement
As an action item from the Sustainability meeting held on October 20, 2009, Stuart Kent was
asked to modify the language in the proposed Mission Statement. The revised statement was
provided to the Committee prior to the meeting for review. The committee adopted the
mission statement as written.
Mission Statement:
The Sustainability Committee of the Glendale City Council will research, conduct outreach,
discuss, analyze, and recommend a unifying course of action entailing three core areas of
Environmental Responsibility, Social Responsibility, and Economic Responsibility. Goals and
strategies will be developed encompassing these areas to allow businesses, residents, city
programs and facilities, and other interested partners the opportunity to participate in making
sustainability a community program.
Ill. Education and Public Awareness Plan
Jo Miller, from Environmental Resources, chairperson for the sub-committee on Education and
Public Awareness presented this item.
Ms. Miller started the presentation by identifying some of the key goals of Public Awareness,
Public Education, and Outreach. She stressed the importance of telling the story of how the
Council Sustainability Committee Minutes
November 17, 2009
Page 2
City of Glendale is leading by example. One of the primary goals of Public Awareness was
meeting the ever-growing public demand for green information for both residents and
businesses with an emphasis on enhancing the quality of life for Glendale residents. Another
approach towards keeping Public Awareness in the forefront would be to communicate
sustainability elements (the balance of economic, environmental, and community concerns)
when making decisions.
Ms. Miller also presented two long-term goals for Public Education and Outreach. The first goal
was to provide information and assistance to the public to enable them to make informed
decisions with respect to air quality, water, energy, heat island effects, the use of natural
assets, and the reduction of environmental footprints. The second long-term goal was to
enhance the livability for Glendale residents, which would instill confidence within our
community.
The presentation suggested ways for developing these goals to strengthen the city's efforts for
sustainability. Ms. Miller stated that the City of Glendale already offers a variety of services,
education programs, and events to help Glendale residents and business owners practice a
green lifestyle.
Some of the existing sustainability-related programs for Public Awareness and Public Education
and Outreach the city has in place were highlighted throughout the presentation.
The Green web page serves as a one-stop shop with shortcuts to many departments and
programs throughout the city. Ms. Miller stated that the Glendale's Green Web Site has been
on line for one year. In addition to being a tool for information for news and events, and city
resources, the site provides a variety of quick links for residents and businesses. To date 4,395
people have visited the web site, with Glendale's Green House being the most popular, with up
to 2,757 hits. Another avenue the city uses is through the Clean & Green Newsletter, which has
doubled the requests for water conservation information. As part of the presentation, Ms.
Miller gave the committee a brief on-line tour of the city's web site, which showed the ease in
which one could navigate through the site. The site includes online videos covering many
topics, links to other websites offering information on sustainability, as well as local rebates and
state and federal government incentives.
The city's involvement in providing public events such as the Green Festival, where more than
800 people attended in 2009; the Teacher's Fair, hosted by Environmental Resources, which
had more than 185 teachers in attendance, and involved participation from 11 environmental
education programs were a few of the examples given for opportunities to contact a wider
public audience. Other successful public events within the city included the Walk & Bike Your
Child to School Day, which is held each year in October; the Bike Rodeos, which are offered
twice a year; and the Cell Phone Recycling Campaign, which is scheduled annually in November.
Council Sustainability Committee Minutes
November 17, 2009
Page 3
Ms. Miller also mentioned that the city has been successful in using Glendale's Cable 11 as a
vehicle for getting information to the public through programs such as Glendale Today, which
aired in the spring of 2009. The program featured the Green Web site and the Glendale Green
Festival hosted by Councilmember Knack. The program "Going Green in Glendale" aired in
2008-09, featured interviews with city experts on transportation, fleet maintenance, recycling,
and water conservation. She also stated that Cable 11 produced a program about Glendale's
partnership with Habitat for Humanity to build the first platinum level LEED home in the state
of Arizona. This program received national recognition at the International Green Build
conference. In addition to those programs, Ms. Miller stated that the SRP and APS Energy Show
is now in the works.
In 2009, the city increased their community education efforts by offering homeowner
workshops on Solar Energy, Organic Vegetable Gardening, Energy Audits, Composting, Natural
Products for the home, Water Harvesting for the Landscape, Setting Your Water Timer, Low-
Water Use Landscape Plants, "Smart" Irrigation Timers, and The Earth-Friendly Back Yard. In
2010, the list of workshops would include Green Remodels, Solar Hot Water 101, Solar PV 101,
and Home Energy Efficiency. The Water conservation Landscape Series provides more than 12
workshops per year, while Glendale University offers advanced classes on water resources and
conservation.
In an effort to blend knowledge with action, community programs were developed to provide
information on weatherization for low-income housing projects. The city has also provided an
on-site water budgeting service, as well as consultations for HOA's, schools, and businesses.
Ms. Miller stated the city is also reaching the younger generation with their Youth Education
programs. There are recycling presentations, a transportation Pace program, xeriscape garden
guided field trips, a water watchers program designed for elementary schools, and the Energy
Efficiency Community Block Grant Program (EECBG) which provides for 60 classroom visits over
a period of three years.
The presentation included a list of twelve regional sustainability related programs and
partnerships with links to their websites. The most recent regional partnership is ASU's
Sustainable Cities Network.
The committee was presented with a list of city comparisons on Sustainability Public
Awareness, General Information, and Sustainability Education. The information was gathered
from seven major city websites, which included Glendale, Chandler, Mesa, Peoria, Phoenix,
Scottsdale, and Tempe.
Ms. Miller mentioned that the most common city comparison trends were that all cities have an
abundance of information on compliance-related environmental programs such as solid waste,
transportation, storm water, air quality, and water conservation. Cities are developing more
Council Sustainability Committee Minutes
November 17, 2009
Page 4
policy initiatives that engage the public, and are developing ways to "share their
green/sustainability story" with residents and the business community.
Ms. Miller offered the committee several ideas for enhancing public input opportunities and for
determining the level of public interest in sustainability. One suggestion was to survey people
who are already seeking green information, while another would be to utilize direct mail
opportunities and continue to provide the existing events to direct people to web site surveys.
Forums could also be designed to engage specific audiences. An example of this would be the
use of business forums on green buildings, residential focus groups, and the like.
Ms. Miller stated that the next step in accomplishing these goals would be to continue to share
information between departments and to work towards integrating those efforts into a
consistent message that "Tells our Story." Other steps included developing a city sustainability
power point presentation, continuing to working with regional programs, maintaining the city's
sustainability practices inventory, and providing updates to the green web site.
Ms. Miller ended with a few additional thoughts for the committee to consider when
contemplating future developments of outreach programs. One consideration is the use of the
EECBG grant that will provide funding for a staff person, and, when possible, integrate new
programs into existing programs in order to leverage resources, next would be continuing to
collaborate regionally on sustainability initiatives, and lastly, monitoring and re-evaluating
economic trends and interests in the business community.
The presentation was well received, and the committee thanked Ms. Miller for her time.
The following suggestions were offered by Chairperson Goulet and Councilmember Knaack with
regard to the topic of education and public awareness:
• City's Green Web-site: Post locations of housing developments with green components
so interested citizens could see what they look like. Staff suggested using ASU Interns to
complete this project.
• Councilmember E-Newsletters: Include sustainability information in e-newsletters.
• Channel 11: Play more programs on energy savings and sustainability topics.
• Connection: Include articles on Sustainability topics.
• Glendale Libraries: Highlight/promote resource materials on sustainability topics.
• GU Graduate level: Offer advance course on sustainability topics.
• Outside Experts: Have outside experts make presentations to city departments and
Council Sustainability Committee.
Council Sustainability Committee Minutes
November 17, 2009
Page 5
Follow up items/questions were made by Chairperson Goulet. Staff will conduct initial research
and report back to the sub-committee at future meeting.
1. Remodeling Report — "What we offer or what people can do that want to make
modifications to their home (existing or new), including Historic Homes and ways to
make modifications to doors, windows, etc., without impacting the historic
designation."
2. Straw-Bale House — "If someone wanted to build alternative structures like this could
they do it and what would it take to get it approved through city process?"
3. Community Garden— "How did they do it and could it be done here?"
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at approximately 11:40 a.m.
NEXT MEETING: December 15, 2009
10:30 a.m. to 11:30 a.m.
Council Chambers Conference Room B-2
TOPIC: Comprehensive Energy Conservation Plan
Respectfully Submitted,
Marilyn L. Clar , ecording Secretary