HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - Minutes - Parks & Recreation Advisory Commission - Meeting Date: 10/16/2006CITY OF GLENDALE,ARIZONA
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE
PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY COMMISSION
HELD MONDAY, OCTOBER 16,2006
GLENDALE MUNICIPAL OFFICE COMPLEX, ROOM B-3
5850 WEST GLENDALE AVENUE
The meeting was called to order at approximately 7:00p.m. by Chairperson Hansen with
Commissioners Eric Simon, Raymond Kultala, Liz Farley, Michael Socaciu, and Sara
Berry. Representing city staff were Deputy Directors Shirley Medler, Karen Hesser, and
Bill Schwind, and Parks Supervisor Bob Rhodes.
Director Becky Benna was absent due to a death in her family.
Chairperson Hansen read the Mission Statement for the record.
I.APPROVAL OF MINUTES —SEPTEMBER 11, 2006, MEETING
Chairperson Hansen called for approval of the minutes.
Chairperson Hansen stated that he read the mission statement at the beginning of the
meeting and it should be noted as the first item in the minutes. He went on to say that on
page 3, item A - 3 should include a paragraph to read: "In addition to public input process
previously described, names may also be solicited from Glendale Parks and Recreation
and the Glendale Marketing and Communications Department".
A motion was made by Commissioner Kultala to accept the minutes as amended.
Commissioner Simon seconded the motion. The motion carried unanimously.
Chairperson Hansen introduced Park and Recreation Commissioner Liz Farley and asked
that she share with everyone a little bit about herself. Commissioner Farley stated she
moved to Arizona from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. She resides in the Sahuaro District
and has been in the valley for 11 years. She stated the Mayor contacted her and asked if
she was interested in volunteering for the Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission.
Chairperson Hansen stated the Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission consists of
nine members, two of which are students. He asked the Commission members to
introduce themselves. He named the Commissioners that were absent this evening.
II. PARKS MAINTENANCE STANDARDS AND INSPECTION REVIEW
Ms. Shirley Medler introduced Ms. Karen Hesser and Mr. Bob Rhodes who will be
presenting this item.
Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission Meeting Minutes
October 16, 2006
Page 2
Deputy Director Karen Hesser is responsible for Parks, Rangers, and Aquatic
Maintenance operations. She presented the Commissioner with packets of information,
including a copy of the PowerPoint presentation that Parks Supervisor Bob Rhodes will
be presenting.
Mr. Rhodes stated that the parks maintenance service levels and standards were
developed as a result of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. He explained that it was
developed in 2001 and implemented over the past few years. He said new facilities, such
as new park sites, or other areas of responsibility are to be included in the process. He
explained there are four levels of service established to maintain the various sites. He
said the frequency of usage increases or decreases and the levels of service increase or
decrease.
Mr. Rhodes said that whether department staff is maintaining the facility or a contractor is
responsible for the facility, staff and visitors expect to have a level of consistency. He
said this is accomplished by having the guidelines and standards followed and the same
expectations required.
Mr. Rhodes continued by describing the changes in standards over the past several years.
He used the example that over the last ten years staff has addressed water reduction. He
said that while there has to be a process of water use reduction there needs to be minimal
impact on the plant material. Additionally, Mr. Rhodes explained that safety inspections
are required of all playground equipment and that the inspections are conducted once a
week by a nationally certified playground inspector. This person is also responsible to
make any repairs to the equipment.
Chairperson Hansen asked if this person would be city staff. Mr. Rhodes stated yes.
Mr. Rhodes continued by explaining that there are different types of turf. He explained
that it is important to maintain the turf at every level.
He described how the standards were created. He said staff began with the identification
of specific maintenance tasks. He added there is a comparison of existing parks to
outside source standards.
Mr. Rhodes said staff set standards for each task identified. Staff reviewed maintenance
frequency of each park.
Mr. Rhodes reviewed the tasks within modes of service such as irrigation/inspections, the
turf, trees and shrubs, litter, park/site inspections, playground inspections, soil testing,
ball field renovation,planting beds, and restroom cleaning.
As a point of comparison, Mr. Rhodes reviewed the staffing levels of some parks that
Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission Meeting Minutes
October 16, 2006
Page 3
have specific staff assigned, including Sahuaro Ranch, Thunderbird, North and South
Bonsall, Murphy Park and the combination of the western area regional park and the
Grand Canal Linear Park.
Mr. Rhodes said the city contractors with Mariposa Landscaping to provide maintenance
of the parks. He displayed slides and explained the areas of the Bethany Home Outfall
Channel (Grand Canal Linear Park), retention basin at 83'a and Maryland Avenues,
Bicentennial Park, Foothills Dog Park, Sahuaro Ranch Ball Fields, Foothills Library, and
Sunset Vista Park.
Commissioner Socaciu asked if parks that weren't over-seeded for the winter would
remain as dirt. Mr. Rhodes explained that parks are not left as dirt but rather are cut
lower and Bermuda grass is left dormant until spring. He described when and which
parks would be fertilized and over seeded for the winter as well as those that would be
prepared for the spring.
Chairperson Hansen stated the latest issue of National Recreation and Park magazine that
the Commission receives, readers requested more information regarding dog parks,
attesting to the increasing popularity if this particular type of park. Deputy Director
Hesser shared that at the recent NRPA Congress in Seattle, she attended a session on dog
parks and that it was "Standing Room Only", confirming Mr. Hansen's assertion.
After reviewing the list of parks and their maintenance providers, Commissioner Socaciu
asked for clarification that if no one is listed under "contract" should it be assumed the
City maintains that park? Ms. Hesser said that was correct.
Commissioner Socaciu expressed concerns with the condition of the Bethany Outfall
Channel. Mr. Rhodes explained that the city has not accepted the park back from the
contractor. He added the city has begun the process however, with the walk through
process.
Commissioner Socaciu inquired about the length of time a dead plant would remain on
site. Mr. Rhodes stated that if there are dead plants or trees on site, staff's first
responsibility is to identify why the plant or tree has died before another tree or plant is
planted. Commissioner Socaciu stated that he would like deed items removed
immediately whether or not they are replaced.
Commissioner Socaciu stated that it shouldn't come to the point where residents must
complain about something in the park. He stated that most residents will not complain
until they have had to deal with the same issue repeatedly.
Commissioner Kultala asked about the types of tree programs that city offers. Mr.
Rhodes stated the city has "Dedicate a Tree Program" and added there are brochures
Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission Meeting Minutes
October 16, 2006
Page 4
located throughout the city at various offices. Ms. Medler stated this brochure could be
mailed to those interested in the program.
Commissioner Simon asked what criteria is used to determine who will maintain a
particular park, whether by city or contracted staff. Mr. Rhodes explained that high use
sites are maintained by staff but with rapid growth sometimes it is necessary to contract
out these sites, at least temporarily.
Commissioner Simon asked how many staff was needed to maintain the Thunderbird
Conservation Park. Ms. Hesser said there is one full-time and one part-time staff member
at the site. Ms. Medler went on to explain that quite a number of volunteers assist in park
and trail maintenance at Thunderbird Park.
Chairperson Hansen questioned how the modes were established. Mr. Rhodes explained
that the modes are established typically on the size of the park, the different features it
offers, and the amount of use.
Commissioner Farley asked if the modes were revisited with the older park renovations
being completed. Mr. Rhodes said yes, that as a result of the renovations, the parks
maintenance levels were increased.
Chairperson Hansen asked when the new standards were effective. Mr. Rhodes stated the
standards were implemented in 2003. He added any major changes to the standards need
to be reviewed with the contractors as they based their landscaping fees on a year-to-year
basis.
Chairperson Hansen thanked staff for reformatting the park inspection sheets distributed
this evening, as they were much clearer.
Mr. Rhodes reminded each Commissioner to add his or her name to the top of the
inspection sheet in the event a staff member would like to make contact.
Chairperson Hansen asked for the Department staff number in case any commissioners
would like to fax their inspection report into the office.
III. UPCOMING EVENTS AND PROGRAMS
Ms. Shirley Medler stated that staff would provide a spreadsheet on a quarterly basis
indicating all upcoming parks and recreation events. The Commission thanked staff for
the information. Commissioner Socaciu asked that the events be placed in chronological
order. Chairperson Hansen agreed adding that the Wiffle Ball World Series is scheduled
to take place in a couple of weeks followed by the Jingle Bell Hike. Commissioner
Socaciu asked that an electronic copy be sent to the Commission so that they may sort the
Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission Meeting Minutes
October 16, 2006
Page 5
events themselves. Ms. Medler offered to sort and send the chart to the Commission.
Ms. Medler introduced Bill Schwind, new Deputy Director for Capital Improvements,
Planning, and Intergovernmental Agreements. Mr. Schwind provided his background
information on his work experience for the Commission.
IV. PARKS AND RECREATION ORGANIZATIONAL CHART AND MAJOR
RESPONSIBILITIES
Ms. Medler suggested this item be continued to next month's meeting. She distributed an
organizational chart that included the administrative Parks and Recreation management
and their areas of responsibility. She explained the major duties of those listed on the
organization chart and some potential changes.
V. CITIZEN COMMENTS:
There were none.
VI. STAFF REPORTS
Ms. Medler stated that Mr. Rex Gulbranson, liaison to the Arts Commission, has
invited the Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission to the Public Art Tour,
scheduled for October 21 from 9:30 to noon. Chairperson Hansen indicated he
would be attending.
Ms. Medler thanked those Commissioners who attended the grand opening of the
Foothills Recreation and Aquatics Center. She distributed a marketing brochure
related to the Center.
Ms. Medler discussed the Glendoberfest, which is Glendale's Halloween
Celebration. This will take place at Sahuaro Ranch Park on Tuesday, October 31.
Ms. Hesser stated an Eagle Scout conducted a project at the Thunderbird Park
Viewing Blind on October 7. She added the Scouts were well received by the
neighbors. She noted the splash pads are now closed for the winter season.
Mr. Schwind stated he would be presenting an overview of the capital
improvement projects before the Commission once it is prepared. Chairperson
Hansen stated that he recalls at the previous CIP review, Commissioner Socaciu
stated he would like to have more input. Mr. Schwind stated he would like as
much input from the Commission as possible.
Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission Meeting Minutes
October 16, 2006
Page 6
VII. COMMISSION COMMENTS
Commissioner Simon stated he and his wife attended the Foothills Recreation and
Aquatics Center grand opening. He stated Mrs. Simon noticed there are no
restrooms on the second floor. Ms. Medler stated due to budget constraints
restroom facilities are located on the first floor only in that section of the building.
However, a drinking fountain is located on the second floor. He felt that this issue
should be revisited in the near future.
Chairperson Hansen asked Commissioner Berry for an update of school sporting
events. Commissioner Berry stated that the cross-country team practices at
Thunderbird Conservation Park.
Chairperson Hansen stated he attended the Foothills Recreation and Aquatics
Center grand opening and he found the staff was well trained and informed. He
asked that the Foothills Park link be updated as it still shows a vacant lot. He
noticed there was some planting of Sahuaro Cactus at Thunderbird Park. Ms.
Hesser stated that this was a reclamation project with the Streets Division and that
Parks Division staff were able to secure and acquire sahuaros and have them
installed at Thunderbird Conservation Park. Mr. Hansen asked if the Commission
could review the operational plan. Ms. Hesser stated that staff is currently in the
process of completing the plan and will make it available to the Commission as
soon as possible. Chairperson Hansen asked if anything would be done with the
charred trees along
59th Avenue at the Thunderbird Park. Ms. Medler stated
59th
Avenue is scheduled to be improved in the near future. She will check on the
plans for the trees and report back to the Commission.
Chairperson Hansen congratulated staff on being awarded a $150,000 NRPA
grant for youth football. Ms. Medler explained the NRPA has partnered with the
NFL and has awarded money which is reserved to inventory at infrastructure such
as sportsfields, space available, and different organizations that are involved in
order to collaborate efforts to serve the youth of the communities. She explained
that a lot of city facilities are constructed as multi purpose fields, which allow for
flexibility. Glendale is receiving more recognition nation wide for our sports
programs.
Chairperson Hansen stated that he had attended "After the Sun Goes Down" skate
court event that took place a couple of months ago during a previous Commission
meeting. He raised the issue regarding individuals that did not utilize safety
equipment. She stated that anytime staff is supervising the facility, safety
equipment should be used.
Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission Meeting Minutes
October 16, 2006
Page7
Chairperson Hansen asked when the Park and Facility Naming Guidelines would
be heard before the City Council. Ms. Medler stated she would check on when
this is scheduled to be discussed with Council.
Commissioner Simon reminded staff that there was previous discussion about
holding the November Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission meeting at the
Adult Center. Ms. Medler confirmed that the next meeting would be held at the
Adult Center on November 13th
Chairperson Hansen asked for any topics of interest for the next Commission
meeting and Commissioner Simon suggested an update regarding the proposed
plans for the second floor of the Adult Center.
Commissioner Socaciu asked if there was a demand for use of the second floor.
Ms. Medler explained that the business plan does include proposed use of the
second floor and added that staff is researching information related to centers of
this type and size to establish a business plan for the Adult Center.
Commissioner Simon asked what the purpose was for the second floor. Ms.
Medler stated it was designed to be improved as demand for increased use was
realized.
Commissioner Farley stated the three Commission Goals were tabled and he
asked when they would be brought off the table. Chairperson Hansen confirmed
that item #5 had been tabled to see what would develop. He said #6 has been
completed. Chairperson Hansen said#2 and 4 needs to be addressed. Ms. Medler
stated she would check into this. She added a meeting would be scheduled at the
Foothills Recreation and Aquatic Center in the spring. Chairperson Hansen stated
if this were the case, the center would have 6 months of operation which could be
discussed.
VIII. NEXT MEETING SUGGESTED AGENDA ITEMS
IX. NEXT MEETING: Monday, November 13, 2006 at 7pm at the Glendale Adult
Center.
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 9:03 p.m.
Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission Meeting Minutes
October 16, 2006
Page 8
Diana Figueroa, Recording Secretary