HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - Minutes - Parks & Recreation Advisory Commission - Meeting Date: 11/14/2011CITY OF GLENDALE, ARIZONA
PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY COMMISSION MEETING
6:00 P.M., MONDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 2011
ROSE LANE RECREATION CENTER
5003 W. MARLETTE AVENUE
MEMBERS PRESENT:Jonathan Liebman, Chair
Donna Williams, Vice Chair
Jamie Aldama
Patrick Church
Allison Tedford
Gary Parr
Rachel Nowakowski
MEMBERS ABSENT: Samantha Cooke
OTHERS PRESENT: Erik Strunk, Executive Director
Bill Schwind, Deputy Director
Karen Hesser, Deputy Director
David Seid, Recreation Manager
Deanna Ortiz, Recreation Manager
Zach Skinner, Senior Recreation Coordinator
Darrell Reagan, Senior Recreation Coordinator
Christine Frederickson, Management Assistant
I.CALL TO ORDER
Chair Liebman called the meeting to order at 6:02 p.m.
II. ROLL CALL
Chair Liebman welcomed all present and noted that Commissioners
Church and Cooke were absent.
III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF THE OCTOBER 17, 2011, MEETING
Item to be addressed after the facility tour.
IV. BUSINESS FROM THE FLOOR
Item to be addressed after the facility tour.
Commissioner Church entered the meeting at 6:04 p.m.]
V. TOUR OF ROSE LANE FACILITY
Mr. Darrell Reagan, Senior Recreation Coordinator, took the
Commissioners on a tour of the indoor areas of the Rose Lane
Recreation Center, which included the following areas:
Parks and Recreation
Advisory Commission Meeting
November 14, 2011
Page 2
Arts and Crafts Room
Kitchen
Office
Multi-Purpose Room
Recreation Room equipped with pool table, foosball table,
television and air hockey table
Homework area
Small Play/Quiet Time Room
Mr. Reagan, provided the following details regarding the afterschool
program at Rose Lane:
Thirty-five children are currently enrolled.
Program hours are 3:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m.
The program is for children in 1' through 8th grade.
The resident program cost is $35 per child per semester.
Mr. Zach Skinner, Senior Recreation Coordinator took the
Commissioners on a tour of the pool and aquatics area.
Mr. Skinner provided the following details regarding the aquatics
program at Rose Lane:
The pool was originally built in 1966 and renovated in 2005.
The 2005 renovation included all new water features, all new
concrete in and around the pool, a new slide and various other
improvements.
There is combination lap pool/diving pool, a smaller pool with a
slide, a splash pad area and a water playground area.
This summer, over 40,000 people used the pool in total.
The lap pool is used by a local high school through the first
week of November for Swim Team practice.
There are twenty-one life-guards on duty each day during the
summer. Of that, sixteen actually work guarding the pool, and
the other five are either on break, manning first aid or servicing
visitors.
On many days, over 1,000 people visited the pool. Typical use
ranged from 600 to 1,000 people a day over the past summer.
The tour concluded at 6:30 p.m.
Chair Liebman praised staff on the improvements at Rose Lane. Chair
Liebman commented that as a product of the City of Glendale Parks
and Recreations programs as a child, he is very proud of the progress
of the city and of the department.
Parks and Recreation
Advisory Commission Meeting
November 14, 2011
Page 3
Commissioner Williams inquired about the snacks provided for the
children in the afterschool program. Ms. Deanna Ortiz replied that the
food is provided from the Kids Café via the St. Mary's Food Bank.
Chair Liebman noted that the staff report provided in the Commission
packet indicates that the Rose Lane sports field generates over
13,000 annually through field rentals, half of which goes to the
General Fund and half of which is spent on facility maintenance and
necessary improvements. Chair Liebman asked if the Parks and
Recreation Department ever receives any part of the half that goes to
the General Fund. Mr. Schwind explained that in the past, 100% of
the revenue went into the General Fund and then a percentage was
allocated back to the Department. However, now only one-half goes
to the General Fund and the other half is put into a self-sustaining
fund for sports field maintenance. Chair Liebman felt that 100% of the
revenue should remain with Parks and Recreation Department.
Commissioner Aldama asked if the maintenance costs for the Rose
Lane sports fields exceed $13,000. Mr. Schwind replied in the
positive. Commissioner Aldama inquired as to how staff acquired the
extra funds to make up the difference between the allocated revenue
and the actual maintenance costs. Mr. Schwind explained that there is
an overall budget for all of the parks as a whole and extra revenue
from some locations is shifted to cover the shortfall in others.
VI. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF THE OCTOBER 17, 2011, MEETING
revisited)
Mr. Strunk introduced Mr. Bob Portillo who will be appointed to the
Commission by the Mayor next Tuesday and will be officially seated at
the December Commission meeting.
Commissioner Parr motioned to approve the October 17, 2011,
meeting minutes as written. Commissioner Williams made the
second. The motion passed 7 — 0.
VII. BUSINESS FROM THE FLOOR (revisited)
None.
VIII. OVERVIEW OF THE SPECIAL INTEREST CLASS PROGRAM
Mr. Schwind stated that the city strives to provide Special Interest
Classes on a wide variety of subjects and interests at a very affordable
rate to the public. Mr. Schwind stated that the goal is to provide
Special Interest Classes city-wide. Offerings at the Foothills
Parks and Recreation
Advisory Commission Meeting
November 14, 2011
Page 4
Recreation and Aquatics Center and the Glendale Adult Center exceed
the classes offered at Rose Lane Recreation Center, O'Neil Recreation
Center and the Glendale Community Center.
Mr. Schwind noted that in the older facilities the Parks and Recreation
centers average 4,000 square feet while the Foothills Recreation &
Aquatics Center for example, is 64,000 square feet. Mr. Schwind
explained that the amount of square footage greatly affects the ability
to offer many programs at one time or in one facility. Mr. Schwind
commented that the square-foot issue is a major reason for why there
are many more classes available at the Glendale Adult Center and the
Foothills Recreation & Aquatics Center versus some of the older
facilities.
Mr. Schwind noted that in the upcoming edition of the My Community
magazine, there will be 365 classes offered over the next three and
one-half months. Mr. Schwind commented that staff strives to find a
variety of offerings by qualified instructors. Mr. Schwind stated that in
the upcoming My Community magazine, residents will find more
diversity in class locations; however overall, 60% of the offerings are
at the Foothills Recreation & Aquatics Center. Staff will continue to
work on adding more class locations. Mr. Schwind explained that
there could possibly be partnerships in the near future whereby
Special Interest Classes could be offered in a variety of locations. Mr.
Schwind stressed that the challenge of obtaining space for classes is
tied into space rental fees, which would have to be included in class
fees charged to participants.
Recreation Manager, David Seid stated that some Special Interest
Classes are core classics, such as photography and fitness; while
others are trend-based, such as certain types of dance and the ever-
changing world of computers and technology. Mr. Seid noted that
staff must review the public interest and popularity of trends to ensure
that the offerings are in demand. Mr. Seid added that it is important
to offer classes at convenient times and convenient locations. Mr. Seid
explained that in this economy, the balance of customer price versus
class production cost is critical.
Mr. Schwind distributed the My Community magazine.
Commissioner Williams asked about feedback on classes. Mr. Seid
replied that a handwritten survey is done at the last class of an
offering. Commissioner Williams inquired about obtaining suggestions
for future classes. Mr. Seid explained that there is an annual Special
Interest Class Fair held at the Foothills Recreation & Aquatics Center
Parks and Recreation
Advisory Commission Meeting
November 14, 2011
Page 5
whereby residents, participants, staff and instructors are invited to
discuss options and offerings.
Mr. Strunk added that staff intends to be more aggressive in seeking
information on the needs of residents. Mr. Strunk stated that it is
important to not only find out what residents want to learn, but where
they want to learn, as this is one of the tenets of the Parks and
Recreation Master Plan.
Mr. Schwind commented that the My Community magazine has really
come to life. Mr. Schwind noted that the Library Department has its
own set of Special Interest Classes which helps to expand the overall
offerings to residents.
Commissioner Williams inquired if there was an area that could be
added to the Parks and Recreation website for class suggestion
submittals. Ms. Frederickson responded in the positive.
Chair Liebman noticed a message on Facebook when the My
Community magazine debuted. Mr. Schwind noted that Facebook is
very good for reaching youths and teens. Chair Liebman stated that
many Generation-Xer's are on Facebook and there is a lot of mass
marketing done on Facebook. Chair Liebman suggested that Facebook
could be used to boost interest and attendance at the Special Interest
Classes. Mr. Strunk agreed adding that the City needs to stay relevant
and consider all marketing opportunities, from newspapers to the use
of smart phone technology.
Commissioner Aldama requested further information on the statistic
that 60% of the Special Interest Classes are offered at the Foothills
Recreation & Aquatics Center. Mr. Schwind explained that due to the
cost recovery requirement of the Foothills Recreation & Aquatics
Center, the majority of classes are offered as there is space available
to do so.
Commissioner Aldama commented that the Parks and Recreation
Department did install lighting at Raymond S. Kellis High School and
asked if there would be a charge to utilize the school during off-hours
for Special Interest Classes. Mr. Strunk explained that the
Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA) was an agreement for the Parks
and Recreation Department to provide lighting in exchange for parking
spaces for Stadium parking and did not include use of the interior
space. Mr. Strunk added that also in the IGA, the Parks and
Recreation Department was allowed use of the ball fields, however,
public demand for the field has not held up as anticipated.
Commissioner Aldama felt that some type of partnership should be
Parks and Recreation
Advisory Commission Meeting
November 14, 2011
Page 6
able to be negotiated for free use of school space for Special Interest
Classes.
Mr. Schwind commented that in the past, IGA's were for five-year
terms, however, they have been recently changed to one-year terms
and it may be possible to negotiate for the use of some indoor space.
Ms. Ortiz noted that there was a previous IGA with Copper Canyon
High School for the Copper Canyon Workforce Development class for
which the Parks and Recreation Department was not charged for
additional room rentals. Commissioner Aldama again stressed that
since the ball fields are not utilized as anticipated in the original IGA,
staff should pursue obtaining no-charge indoor space for offerings.
Commissioner Nowakowski complimented staff on the My Community
magazine, but noted that there are no offerings near 83rd Avenue and
Bethany Home Road. Mr. Schwind agreed and noted that this was a
comment that surfaced during many of the Master Plan discussions.
Mr. Schwind stated that there may be a possible partnership with
Desert Mirage Elementary School as well as the Westgate area for
space to house program/class offerings.
Commissioner Nowakowski asked why the Foothills Recreation &
Aquatics Center was such a large facility. Mr. Schwind explained that
in 2002, the City Council approved a city wide departmental Master
Plan. After a series of public meetings, the voters approved bond
funding in support of the capital improvement budget which consisted
of several large scale projects. Mr. Schwind added that at the same
time, the Western Area Regional Park (WARP) plans were moving
forward, but by the time construction was underway, the economy
took a major downturn and the large-scale plans could not be finished
all at one time. Mr. Schwind explained that the fire station, the
basketball courts, the splash pad and the x-court at the WARP were
completed; however, there were no longer funds in the budget to
begin the recreation, library or aquatic center.
IX. QUARTERLY UPDATE ON PARKS MASTER PLAN
Mr. Strunk stated that the Master Plan Update is a strategic tool for
making parks, open space, facility and recreational program decisions
over the next ten years.
Mr. Strunk noted that there are thirty action items in the Master Plan
Update, which are under the umbrella of Community Standards,
Pricing Models, Potential Capital Improvements and Potential Site
Locations for New Facilities When Available.
Parks and Recreation
Advisory Commission Meeting
November 14, 2011
Page 7
Mr. Strunk gave a PowerPoint presentation, which included the
following highlights:
2002-2011 Plan Accomplishments
o Growth of Park System: 16 new parks
o 5 new facilities
o $43 million in investment
Preservation of Existing Facilities
o 14 park renovations
o $12.5 million in investment
o Keeping older parks current, relevant and excitingto
residents
City Map
o Display of renovated park locations versus new park
locations
Implementation of Best Practices
National Accreditation in 2009
o National Recreation and Parks Association
o Only 100 Parks Departments accredited nationally
o Glendale was only 1 of 8 Parks Departments
internationally to receive a perfect score on the
accreditation test
Awards and Special Recognition
o National Awards
o Arizona Parks and Recreation Association Awards
o Westmarc Best of the West Awards
2011 Update
Public Participation
o Citizen Survey
o Focus Groups
o Public Meetings
o Interviews
o Overall Findings
Recommended Priorities
o Take care of what we have
o Understand maintenance needs to protect the quality of
park assets for future planning and development
o Improve awareness of facilities, services and programs
available to the community
o Complete the Western Area Regional Park (WARP)
o Support the development of non-profit partnerships for
funding development
o Establish and follow prudent standards for amenity
development as the community grows
o Expand/enhance the financial resources of the
Department through multiple means
Parks and Recreation
Advisory Commission Meeting
November 14, 2011
Page 8
Primary Action Plan
Recreation Plan
o Engage alternative service providers
o Develop programs to improve health and lifestyles of
residents
o Enhance quality and accessibility of youth programs
Parks Plan
o Complete WARP
o Develop and improve shade structures and amenities in
parks
o Upgrade restrooms
Long-Term Action Plan
o Develop additional skate/BMX amenities as needed
o Include additional aquatics facilities as needed
o Construct additional multi-purpose athletic fields as
needed
o Develop additional dog parks as needed
Next Steps
o Adopt Update to the Master Plan (December 20th)
o Written Annual Report to Council from Parks and
Recreation Advisory Commission regarding the progress
of the Master Plan Update
o Quarterly updates to the Parks and Recreation Advisory
Commission
Chair Liebman requested that the new Commissioners be provided
with at least the Executive Summary of the Master Plan Update. Mr.
Strunk will follow through on the request.
Chair Liebman praised staff on its hard work and dedication to the
Master Plan Update.
X. DISCUSSION ON COMMISSION OUTREACH EVENT
A list of the options for a scheduled Commission outreach event was
distributed to the Commissioners.
The Commissioners discussed manning booths at the Green Festival
and the Chocolate Affair.
Ms. Ortiz also noted that at the Glitter 'N Glow in January, the staff will
be selling cotton candy and popcorn to raise funds for the Parks and
Recreation Scholarship Fund.
Mr. Schwind added that staff is also negotiating with Camelback Ranch
for some Parks and Recreation Departmental exposure at spring traing
baseball.
Parks and Recreation
Advisory Commission Meeting
November 14, 2011
Page 9
It was agreed by consensus that the Commissioners would man
booths at the Green Festival and the Chocolate Affair for
completion of Commission of Goal #4.
Chair Liebman commented that the Commissioners could also sign up
to work the Glitter 'N Glow as their schedules permit.
XI. COMMISSION WORK PLAN
The Commissioners previously received Work Plan Status Sheets to
record goal completion.
Chair Liebman encouraged continued goal achievement.
XII. STAFF UPDATES
Ms. Hesser provided the following updates:
1. The new entry monument construction for Sahuaro Ranch Park
at 59th Avenue has commenced.
2. The re-dedication event at Bonsai! Park North is scheduled for
December 15, 2011, at 1:00 pm.
3. Staff received most of the fall Park Visit report packets for the
requested November 10 return date. Once all are received, the
summary report will be distributed.
4. Mr. Bill Shepard of the Rose Society of Glendale submitted the
Sahuaro Ranch Park Historical Area's Rose Garden for the
American Rose Society annual award and he accepted the award
for "Medium Garden" at the American Rose Society Annual Rose
Show and Convention held in October in Studio City, CA.
The American Rose Society is divided into 9 districts and Arizona is in
District 8 which includes west Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, southern
Nevada and southern California, and is called the Pacific Southwest
District which is also the largest District in the U.S.
Each year, the Pacific Southwest District presents three awards for
outstanding public gardens. There is one award for "Small Garden"
which is less than 100 rose bushes, one for "Medium Garden" which is
101 to 500 rose bushes and one for "Large Garden" which is 501 or
more rose bushes.
This recognition will be presented at the December 13th
City Council
meeting.
5. Volunteers:
Parks and Recreation
Advisory Commission Meeting
November 14, 2011
Page 10
a. Staff attended the Midwestern University Volunteer Fair
and successfully recruited an additional five volunteers for
the Sahuaro Ranch Historic Areas.
b. The Desert Mirage Adopt-A-Park group began their
monthly work sessions this month. They are held the
first Saturday of the month at the park.
c. Thirty-six volunteers participated in a painting project
along Skunk Creek trail.
d. Twelve volunteers conducted a clean-up at the Sahuaro
Ranch Historic Area.
6. Staff is finalizing negotiations with a vendor to sponsor the "You
Got Caught" cards. Staff training and launch are expected in
the next couple of months and the program will launch in spring
2012.
Mr. Schwind provided an update which included the following:
At the December Council Meeting, Mr. Strunk will present Mayor
and Council with the 10-year renewal contract for the
management and operation of the Paseo Racquet Center.
At the December Council Meeting, the Memorandum of
Understanding between the City of Glendale and Special
Olympics of Arizona will go before the Council regarding a
partnership with facilities and fields.
Construction for improvements at the Glendale Community
Center will commence in mid-December. A total of
approximately $47,000 from a CDBG grant is funding the
project. Improvements include facility repainting, resurfacing of
the outdoor basketball court and new windows and doors.
Ms. Frederickson announced that in the future, along with upcoming
events, a list of volunteer opportunities will be provided to the
Commissioners.
XIII. COMMISSION COMMENTS
Commissioner Parr thanked staff for all of the information provided.
Commissioner Nowakowski appreciated the presentations by staff.
Commissioner Aldama thanked staff for an excellent meeting and for
remaining at work away from their families at night to facilitate the
meeting.
Commissioner Williams felt the meeting was very good.
Parks and Recreation
Advisory Commission Meeting
November 14, 2011
Page 11
Chair Liebman stated that a few months ago, the department was
awarded funds for trail maintenance from the state and asked when
the project would begin. Ms. Hesser replied that there is no date set
as of yet, but the project is still on board with the state trails program.
Chair Liebman commented that all of the parks that he inspected were
in really good shape.
Chair Liebman thanked staff for an informative meeting.
XIV. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 8:06 p.m. by consensus.
The next regular meeting will be Monday, December 12, 2011, at 6:00
p.m. in Room B-3 of the Municipal Office Complex, Glendale, Arizona.
Respectfully submitted,
Denise Kazmierczak